Mojo44

It’s a pick your poison scenario no matter how you look at it. Before I come up with some sense of who we should play next week I want to see how Pittsburgh looks tonight. Particularly Big Ben

Robbed!!!!!!!

That is a fumble! There’s no way they can steal this from us

It don’t come easy

BASS!

Come on defense. Time to close ranks!

How about this time

Frustrating

Incomplete!! No question

Can’t overturn this either

Rivers he’s on his game today

We are getting completely out of class right now

I would love a turnover right now

Murray injured and replaced against the Rams

Tua has been bad today. But his receivers have maybe been worse!

Ken Williams play special teams? I’d love to see him on the active roster.

And this is the “scary” Miami first team defense?

The office has awakened with a vengeance after those first couple of possessions! Love it

That play was so slow developing I’m surprised it worked so well

Please sit Josh now!

No, I am not saying that at all. I say it was questionable because of the level of the hit. All I can do is repeat myself by saying intentionality is a non-factor. Again, a referee cannot read a players mind and that is the only way you can assess premeditation. Or have the player stand trial and cross examine him. All the referee can do is base his judgment on what he sees happening in front of him and not what he may or may not believe what is the mindset of the player at the time. Honestly, this seems very simple to me. Otherwise, we’re getting into a “pre-crime” scenario like in Minority Report

Premeditation cannot be a factor in these calls. A referee cannot be expected to read a players mind. They have to base their judgment on how to play turned out whether it was premeditated or incidental. I agree with you that some of the calls including the one on Milano were questionable.For example, most facemask penalties are not intentional but incidental but you have to call out every time

I remember it, too. I think Dave Casper is the one who recovered it.

I’m curious to know what this move means. For one thing, it could mean that John Brown is ready to go.

Probably top five on the team