Niagara Dude

100%, Cook is a good back but not a 3 down back. Bills need to invest more resources /capital into receiver position not rb. Trade for a 3rd or 4th and draft his replacement. Cook has one of the lowest usage rates in the NFL for starting fb's and he has to come off the field on 3rd down. He put up some good numbers but not elite and look what happened to his brother right after he got paid

Sound like this has been poorly managed or contractors overcharging, the Bills should be getting a done for the net final price

I get it, I just would like to see Beane have a year where he can add a difference maker or two through free agency

I think he has the tools but he needs to get stronger and be more consistent . The Chiefs had him on the ground most of the title game

Are you saying this year it creates 10 mllion

He was worth around 12-14 mllion tops

Beane again handing out overpays and we will forever be over the cap year after year. Team cannot get improve talent through free agency because Beeane never has money to spend and his drafting has not been great .

Beane blew last season and not trading up to get Bryan Thomas , 6"3 and 4.3 forty and already considered a top 8 receiver in the NFL. We could have easily move up past the Jags to get him.

Cap management by Beane needs to improve, I find amazing that this roster has so few all pro level players but always find themselves well over the cap. This is another reason why Beane needs to resist Cook's demands for 15 million. Another blunder is cap money he put into Dawson Knox and then drafts Dalton K

I question if Pegula has his own advisors to properly grade both McDermott and beanie or is everything ignored because Allen carries them to the playoffs on his own with very little support talent and a bunch of no name assistants.

No thanks, he is too slow. The Bills need better speed at the corner position

End of the day, Beane needs to start drafting larger players. This defence is full of players that are either smaller or slower and rely on turnovers to get off the field

The Bills' rushing success last season was a team effort. While Cook was a primary contributor, Josh Allen, Davis, and Johnson played significant roles. It's important to consider Cook's snap percentage when evaluating his contract. Since becoming the starter, he played 55% of offensive snaps in 2023 and only 48% in 2024. This 2024 figure ranked 38th among running backs, considerably lower than league leaders and other top performers. Among the highest-paid running backs in 2024, only David Montgomery had a lower snap percentage than Cook due to sharing the backfield with Jahmyr Gibbs. Beane faces tough decisions this offseason regarding contract extensions. Considering Cook's snap percentage and the contributions of other players, it's reasonable to argue that prioritizing Cook's extension over Christian Benford, Greg Rousseau, Terrel Bernard, and Khalil Shakir may not be the optimal strategy. For me priority should be Shakir/Benford if he is healthy, Bernard, Rousseau and lastly Cook. This is not because I don't like Cook, I think he is very talented. I just don't think he is someone we could not replace in this coming draft so we don't have to overpay him. I also strongly believe you need a top receiver and passing game to win come playoff time. Look at the Super Bowl, the Chiefs totally shut Barkley but could not shut down Eagles receivers. I love Collins and even Shakir, but the Bills and Beane need to get Allen a #1 receiver and a defence that can get more stops.

Just glad the Bills took the guy who showed the best at the combine. Still remember the guys at WGR55 crying that we took the wrong Josh. Only thing that has gone wrong is Beane never getting him a true #1 that could do everything . Diggs was good but did next to zero in the big playoff games This is passing league and team that pass first do well. Bills offseason should be about getting Allen a stud a WR

I like the add a defensive coach from outside but this will never happen because McDermott only want yes men and thinks he is a defensive genius. Yes Andy Reid fired him in Philly because he is useless when it comes to defensives or at least on how to stop playoff level teams. We have not had one play year where our defence has stopped the other team, 3 opening drive TD'S this year and if Mark Andrews does not drop an east pass maybe the Bills are not even in title game because our defence could not stop anyone . One thing that needs to happen, get rid of Hamlin, he is one of worse covering safeties ever. So tired of seeing these small and slow then everyone else players we always seem to have on this team Get some players who are bigger and faster