Lack of production? He doubled his output from 2021. How much more was he supposed to produce, triple his output from 2021? As far as mistakes, fewer drops than Gabe and Knox. He had more first downs than Dawson Knox on 6 fewer catches.
As far as Harty goes, we're paying him a lot more than McKittrick. Harty had one decent year, 2021, with numbers fairly similar to McKittrick's 2022 numbers. He's not a massive upgrade right now, but I'll admit he has potential. As far as Shakir, he only caught 50% of his targets. He's still developing, let's hope he doesn't get the sophomore jinx.