I actually disagree with both of those schools of thought.
My comp for Allen has been Cam Newton. Cam is not accurate. At least, he’s not accurate in the way Brady, Brees and Rodgers are. There’s a reason the Panthers surrounded him with wide catching radius bodies at WR. But Cam’s still an MVP. He’s still a franchise QB. Just a different one.
Josh needs to work on his touch on swing passes. On his timing with deep passes. On going through his reads. But lots of young QBs have things to work on.
I’ve said this for weeks now. If you think Allen will ever be surgical in the way Brady is, you may be waiting a long time. But you don’t need surgical accuracy to be better a franchise QB.
I wish he hit that pass, but it wasn’t keeping me up at night.