BringBackOrton

Murray is out of the league, isn't he?

He reminds me of a young Tyrod.

If the Bills fire Dennison and keep TT, we'll hear retroactive excuses about how he's never had the same OC and how much that's crippled his growth. The cycle will always continue.

Another lotto ticket.

It's the 21st century dude. Every team needs a third string QB who plays special teams.

I was probably the second most vocal poster on this board in favor of drafting Watson. I was begging for it. You're preaching to the choir my man. Yeah he might've. Hard to say. I just know the way it worked out, and that was with a ring. I doubt Kubiak has any regrets about not getting TT on board. Obviously there's a bit of a difference between Downing and Kubiak and what was offered to EJ and TT. But I think a lot of it is familiarity, not necessarily ability. We didn't bring in guys like Kaelin Clay and Tolbert because we knew how secretly good they were (at least I hope not.) We brought them in because the coaches knew them and were familiar with them. And you see that across the league constantly.

Nooooo, Kubiak might not have won a Superbowl in Denver if Tyrod was on that team. That would've been sad. Todd Downing was EJ's QB coach and that was the team that signed him. A vote of confidence, no doubt. The EJ Rebirth In Vegas, coming in 2018.

That's exactly my thought. And why I'd like to grab them earlier. I'd like Evans in particular on the roster, getting a feel for the playbook etc. If he beats out Petey, awesome. If not, a 3rd stringer STer got cut for nothing. Oh well.

You're actually arguing that Geno Smith would win more games as a QB that Eli Manning. I didn't even think that was possible. Reality is truly stranger than fiction. It's telling that the QB's you choose to compare TT to are EeeeeeeeeeJJJJJjjjjj and Cardale. Young star QB's no doubt.

This is what half of the people want for a rookie QB. Who cares if he rides the pine? I don't care about not cutting EJ. But it was clear he was toast after 2014 and it's now 2017 almost 2018 and we still haven't drafted a QB high and that's a HUGE problem.

What? Eli was throwing a 2:1 TD:INT ratio. No chance Geno pulls that off. They won't win another game with him under center. Which is exactly what the brass wants.

EJ wouldn't have been so bad if the Bills tried to get another QB after him. They let EJ shackle them for 4 years (and counting). THAT'S the worst thing about the EJ pick.

Tyrod never saw live bullets with Kubiak. And good thing he didn't. Might've cost him that Superbowl.

Eli was benched because the Giants don't want to win games. He's being benched because he's too good. Complete opposite.

Drafting JP and EJ wouldn't have been so bad if the Bills weren't idiots.

TT goes through OC's like toilet paper.

The worst receiving corp in history changes every year, apparently. Let's go 3/3!

Nah, TT was playing awful and lacked confidence. He looked way better against the Chiefs, especially in the first half.

Of course I did. I still do.

Fella, we could be 16-0 when Tyrod plays for us, but if that mean we have 16 years of going less than 8-8, I don't particularly care.

Did Eli give his coach temporary insanity and get himself benched for a horrible QB? Nope!

No lie, look it up. We haven't finished greater than .500 in a season since Doug Marrone.

Eli never got hurt or played so poorly he got benched for a fifth round rookie. So, yes.

Fake news. We have never finished over .500 since TT came here. The Giants have finished over .500 7 seasons since Eli. That's why nobody in the NFL who knows anything does "blind resumes." Because it's useless. No GM in the NFL cares if Tyrod has a minuscule difference in TD% compared to Eli.

When he's enshrined in the annals of football history and Tyrod is a footnote, who will weep for the minor difference in TD%?