GunnerBill

Thanks Amari, now.... hometown discount, $12m AAV for two years to stay a chase a ring. What say you?

He will be extended. That shows his value but also the value of coaching and knowning the system. That is why Hamlin continues to start. The way the Bills defense communicates and then moves in unison is so high level. Sean McDermott does not get enough credit for how good a defensive mind he is and I think generally Bobby Babich is doing a hell of a job as a first year coordinator. And while I am on it.... Orlovsky is one of the best analysts about at the moment. The list of guys I genuinely learn from doing Xs and Os breakdowns isn't massive but he is on it. I like him as a color guy on commentary too. Awful QB. Good football analyst. They had more elite players. Mahomes, Kelce, Hill, Jones and Mathieu. The Bills probably had fewer weaknesses. The Chiefs had more star power.

I think Daboll and Schoen are going to survive and get a chance to pick their own QB. Just my sense from the vibes out there. I agree the five certainties are: Jets Saints Jags Bears Cowboys I think the 6th most likely is still Eagles, Sirianni has to win a playoff game to survive IMO. My surprise that hasn't been mentioned so far is the Rams. That would be a stepping away rather than a firing but I think Stafford looks pretty washed. They will be too good to be in position to draft a guy and I'm not sure McVay strikes me as a guy who wants to stay and work in QB purgatory.

Yea was a breakdown somewhere between Benford and Rapp. It is a classic cover 2 beater that play precisely because it attacks the region of the field where the corner passes off to the safety but you are right it looks like Benford never plays it as his assignment and Rapp isn't even looking. Definitely a play where the Bills got lucky that the Chiefs didn't execute. There were a couple of those for each team.

It is this IMO. He just looked out of shape to the naked eye too. I know people say olinemen always look like that! But you can spot an out of shape one once you know what their playing weight looks like.

My answer is here. But add to that as a 6th round rookie he actually beat Van Demark out for the swing tackle job in camp despite Vandy having a year in the system. Go back to the inactives those early weeks before Grable was hurt. He was up and Vandy wasn't dressing. We saw what he can do on Sunday when called up on.... and Grable beat that out as a rookie. I think his ceiling is very high indeed.

Sky Sports got it wrong first. Think the Beeb just copied. I hate the BBC's NFL articles though. They are written like a BBC soccer report and the language is just clunky from an NFL perspective.

I think the athleticism, size and strength stand out. Huge guy, quick feet, good bend, has the physical traits you look for. Late conversion to playing tackle but his hands were really impressive he fires them out and wins reps by getting first contact. As I understood it the knock on him coming out was his rawness, especially in the run game where he is liable to take bad angles. Have to say in the pre-season that weakness really didn't show up. I think he is someone who could be a starting tackle in the NFL with a bit of seasoning. Possibly as early as next year. He likely won't get that chance here with Dion and Spencer locked in but I wonder in 2026.... maybe. Dion would be 32, is he someone who is gonna play well into his 30s? Maybe, maybe not.

Hmm. I think it was very similar. And it took him a year to re-imagine his run game once teams got to the code to shutting down the outside stretch zone.

His OC has struggled too. It is almost always the case with Shanny disciples. They know the playbook. They know the scheme. They don't understand the scheme the way Kyle Shanahan does. It is why for years McVay struggled to beat him head to head. Shanny knew how to stop his own offense and McVay didn't know the scheme as well as him to be able to adjust. McVay became a better coach in 2020 when he started to add his own wrinkles to the playbook. Can Slowick get to that point?

That "re-sign Bates and sign Saffold" offseason was depressing. I hated it at the time and predictably it failed.

And Grable. Who trust me is the best of the bunch.

Not might on the Bills TD. That was baltent OPI and the biggest missed call of the night. 2nd was the facemask on Johnson. 3rd was the non-review of the drop inside 2 minutes (not on the on field refs). I also thought on Gray's first TD that the Chiefs had an illegal formation with not enough guys on the line, but it was tight.

He has been aggressive since 2020. Particularly on 4th downs. And the numbers support that

If that is true McD's gut must align with analytics very consistently. Because over 5 years he is top 5 of going with the numbers.

The Bills would definitely sign him at that price. He will get more than that. I think they will sign him anyway, but it will be at a higher rate than that. I'm still on the fence about signing Shakir. But I think the Bills love him.

I think he will ask for Surtain money. I don't think he is as good as Surtain.

Torrence has 2 years left. He isn't a FA until after 2026.

There is a fair gap between those two though isn't there? Surtain is $24m AAV. Agree though for earning potential he should want to be outside and with Watson out they are gonna need to use him there I think.

They did end up moving McDuffie more outside 2nd half. But agree he hasn't been at his best this year.

I just think the difference in plans represents the difference in the offenses that we were facing. In 2021 he was averaging 305 ypg and 3.5 TDpg and the Bills said you will get your yards we are going to make you work hard for every yard and buckle down in the redzone and he threw for 272 and 2 TDs. This year he is averaging 245 ypr and just over 1TD pg and the Bills said okay we are gonna come and challenge you because you might struggle moving the ball if we do that and if you make a few explosives on us, fine, we trust our offense to keep up and he threw 3 touchdowns, but struggled moving the ball and only had 196 yards and the Bills offense more than kept up. They were both really good plans against the version of the Chiefs they were facing. Now we gotta get the plan right if we see them again and pray our key guys are healthy.

There were three throws on KC's final touchdown drive that were real needle thread passes. I think it was to Gray, Hopkins and Watson and on all three of them the window to put the ball was very small and Mahomes found the gap. Makes me wonder a bit if the recent interceptions have made him slightly gun shy earlier in the game from taking on those tight window throws. Because it only seemed to happen when they were in "gotta have it" mode.

I think it is joint with the famous "no blitz" game by Leslie Frazier in the 2021 regular season when we beat them 38-20. Two extremely different plans but both very effective for the different type of Chiefs teams they were deployed against.

Definitely played better as this year has gone on. I remain convinced he came back overweight and wasn't at his ideal playing weight for week 1.

They called some play action shots down the field on early downs that Josh came off to throw short because there was no separation downfield. The Bills had more shot plays called yesterday than any other game all season. They were definitely looking to attack the Chiefs downfield.