GunnerBill

Kincaid just hasn't played very well this year. I don't think it is coaching. I don't think is it scheme. It is him. When you watch the all22 you consistently see a guy struggling against man coverage and overrunning the passing windows in zone. He has, without question, been the 2nd most effective tight end on the Bills in 2025 and personally I'd be basically sitting him at this point and going almost full time with Knox.

It's just easier said than done. They sold out to play run vs us which meant playing a ton more zone than normal behind it. The Bills conversly played a lot of man and sent 5 more than normal vs KC.

There is only the Saints left and he just withdrew. So no, he can't.

He was. Although he was under Ray Rhodes first. There are a few guys who feature in both the Walsh tree and the Parcells tree as I said in the post: Payton, Daboll, Campbell being the three main ones.

Great for Kelvin. Helped I think by the fact the Dline coach who was "next in line" had already been poached by Vrabel to be DC in New England. The Lions staff being plucked. EDIT: Ben Johnson has nicked Antwaan Randle El as his receivers coach and JT Barret as his QB coach too. One presumes Mark Brunell will take the Detroit OC job.

In that scenario? Easy call. Go for 2. Josh Allen from the 2 yard line or Pat Mahomes having the ball again? Easy. The harder call is same situation, 30 seconds left. Where I think it is really tricky to call. I'd lean kick I think because I want the Chiefs to come out playing more conservative and certainly in their own half only having 3 downs not 4. I think 30 seconds, a couple of timeouts and 4 down football your chances of stopping them are next to nil.

Great news.

Coaching staffs were just much smaller generally.

I'm not that old.

I knew the Carter story. Wasn't aware of the extent of Brown's tree. Weren't Lombardi and Landry on the same Giants staff at one poin too?

Similarities in that he liked to use dime in particular but he was blitz heavier.

Seattle is on there. MacDonald from the Harbaugh branch of the Reid/Holmgren branch.

Of the five "branches" of the tree, three are sourced from offense and Seifert and Rhodes are sourced from defense. And what they both ran were 4-3 schemes that played zone coverage on early downs and then lots of heavy nickel and dime on 3rd down. I think that is pretty influential on the defenses you see in the league today. It was the basis of the 4-3 under Pete Carroll won a Superbowl with in Seattle and heavily influences a lot of the schemes you see. There is more variance on D than on O though, because there is still a strong 3-4 contingent of defensive coordinators around.

I was actually prompted to think about this in the odd "Reid disrespects McDermott" thread yesterday. I started thinking about the Reid tree, which is really the Holmgren tree, which is really the Bill Walsh tree.... and then I went down the rabbit hole and.... OH WOW! We are living in a Bill Walsh world. Of the 31 NFL Head Coaches currently employed only one - Mike Vrabel of the Patriots - has no link to the Bill Walsh tree. There was a time when the Walsh tree and the Parcells tree were seen as somewhat equal and while it is true that there are guys on the Walsh tree who also feature on the Parcells tree: Payton, Daboll, Campbell (and his guys) you can't get to anything like 30/31 for Parcells. This league is now fully under the influence of that lineage. Talk about leaving a legacy! Anyway, the image below is my visual representation of it (apologies for image quality it wouldn't upload in higher res, will try and fix) Link to clearer version of image

The Bills did expect Josh to handle it but a big part of the signing of Morse after his rookie year was to help Josh with protection calls. Think Mitch did a lot of the heavy lifting those next couple of seasons in that regard.