Buddy was not perfect but he laid the foundation. His inherited a mess, one of the worst rosters in the N F L . He came in stabilized things , started drafting well, not perfect. Troupe was injured so no telling what he could have been. Buddy also nailed a bunch of picks that we take for granted but many teams blow high picks. The Bills did for many years before Buddy. Mike Willimas , Whitner, Maybin ect.
As for the 2010 draft. Take a close look that is one horrible draft class across the board.
As for picking Gailey, I am not sure what his options were at the time. The team was in shambles.
Arron Williams , Gilmore, searcy, Bradham, Darius, Glenn, that is a solid core.