BarleyNY

That’s a different argument. Having good depth players is better than having poor ones. But that was not what the OP said. He said that a team is only as good as it’s weakest link. That’s very different. Kelvin Benjamin was our starter (sadly). Replace him with a difference maker like Deandre Hopkins or OBJ and you see what I’m taking about. Lots less to worry about who our 4th or 5th WR is in that case. The depth of the roster is for special teams, developmental and role players. You want them to be serviceable when pressed into action, but except for Nick Foles which of them wins you games?

I agree. Ridiculous to put a raw rookie QB behind that OL with that WR corps. Ive been saying that for close to a year now. I have my doubts about Allen, but he certainly showed me something last season. He performed better than I expected under those circumstances. He’s got a chance...... I do like the Dorsey hire. Someone like that needs to be on the staff. He’s a good choice.

Honestly, in today’s NFL with the hard salary cap it doesn’t really work that way. It’s about fielding as many difference makers as possible (including a QB) to go along with solid starters and good role players. The bottom of the roster means little.

Maybe it was sarcasm? There it is

It would be extremely concerning if this was not Allen’s team this year. I’m glad he checked that box. Guesstimate the odds at whatever you choose, but the Bills took their QB and pushed in with him. That was the correct thing to do. Now we find out if it was with the right QB. Buckle up!

What do you see his role as? Assuming specials and subs. Dime? Only things I know about him is what I read on draft sites.

I miss Carl’s takes so much. This is a reasonable take. It’s optimistic, but very close to my prediction. I’d split the Jets series and say 9-7 or 8-8 if we lose to Baltimore, but, hey, who knows?

He didn’t say “only”. He said he was “a main reason”. Big ego? Obviously. Correct? Also yes.

This is correct. Lots of fans want the players to all be humble, which I get. Boisterous truths can rub people the wrong way. I get that too. But OBJ is right. He was one of the few things making the NYG team watchable. They were and continue to be a train wreck. I don’t blame him for wanting to get out of there and go somewhere he has a chance to win.

You honestly think that Mayfield came up with the Pats moving to 2 to draft him all by himself? That would’ve been something from his agent. Incidentally, I heard a rumor that Belichick loved Baker and that the Pats were investigating how far they could move up if he started to fall. It was one of dozens of predraft rumors everyone hears, but it sure fits here. I am surprised he didn’t say Broncos at 2. There’s a video of his draft day party. Just minutes before the draft officially started his agent tells him that they Broncos have a deal in place for 2 and that they’re taking him there.

Don’t blame him. Gotta have that deal signed first.

That is sad

I think it’s only fair that the results of the last Super Bowl be stricken from the record. The Saints can go play the Pats. This Sunday. In New Orleans.

I love being on lakes. The ocean, not as much.

Exactly. You can NEVER tell if a team is going to be really good from the preseason, but sometimes you can tell that they’re going to be really bad. That’s about it. The best indication that you might be good is that they’re really not trying in the preseason.

The double standard is what I was alluding to. Many people here will explain away whatever the Bills do and rip others for doing the same things. Your post is a pretty good example of that. Also most here didn’t have an issue with Shady s deal. He was integral to that offense - as Zeek is to Dallas’s. The two situations are very similar. I understood what the Bills were doing trying to win with Tyrod, Shady and defense. IF that’s the plan, then having (and paying) a back like Shady is necessary. My problem was with that being the plan. They needed a big rebuild around a new FQB. Dak is a better QB than Tyrod but I’d want better for my team. He MIGHT be good enough though. If Dallas thinks he is, then they need a back like Zeek and they have to pay him. The alternative is to start over and that’s a tough sell to fans. As for Gary, I didn’t mean that I think he’s ready to take over. I was just pointing to how often people post things like “just draft a RB in the fourth or fifth round and plug him in”. Dunno. I’d like to see the numbers on that. It sure seems like the majority have been against teams paying the last 3 or 4 RBs looking for big, new deals. Also seems like a majority here were okay paying McCoy.

Bills fans: Teams would be stupid to pay even top running backs. If they we smart they’d just trade them away and draft their replacement on day 3 before they have to pay them. They break down early anyway. Also Bills fans: We love Shady. Happy to have him. So what if he’s still one of the highest paid RBs in the league? The contract was fair - he is a premier RB after all. Poor 2018 season? That was the OL’s fault. He’ll be fine. Besides, we don’t have anyone that can adequately replace him. Yeah, I know we drafted Singletary, but that was in the THIRD ROUND. He can’t do what Shady can. So what if he’s over 30? He’s still got it.

Important difference. Honestly I think his best option would be to hold out long enough to get the Chargers to agree not to tag him for next season. Then LAC gets him for Rivers’ last season and a comp pick down the line while he gets his contract in a year.

Shhhhh! Dude, it’s a family forum.

Not sure how you make that comparison. Kinda ridiculous actually. Watch the players play. Does he? Last 4 seasons: Gordon: 897 carries for 3628 yards 182 receptions for 1577 yards 5205 combined yards Shady: 885 carries for 3814 yards 175 receptions for 1334 yards 5148 combined yards I am not saying that he should get Bell money, but he’s worth a pretty good contract. IMO he’s definitely in the $10M-$11M AAV range.

Gotta agree with that. I can’t believe that he actually wrote that the Steelers had AB, but failed to make the playoffs. He kind of neglected the fact that they made it every other year he played there. He also didn’t bring up players like Tyreek Hill. And he neglected to note that while the Patriots don’t have a true #1 WR they have possibly the best QB ever on the team. So yeah, lots of ways to skin a cat. A stud WR sure does help. I do think the relative VALUE of a stud WR can be argued, but the Forbes guy didn’t really go down that road. He just made a logically invalid argument by picking and choosing examples that fit his hypothesis. The 2020 draft looks like a really good one for WRs so hopefully we can snag a great one.

That sounds right. The Chargers seem to do stuff like that a lot though. I understand that both sides have to negotiate, but they are one of the teams that comes off as Bush League. They could’ve had that final deal from the start. Instead, they held it up and created unnecessary drama and ill will. Plus they contributed to their bad reputation. They literally went after something that the agent could not agree to without costing himself his business. Poor management has been a long standing problem for the Chargers. That was the reason Eli Manning wouldn’t play there and it certainly was alluded to at that time. Now we have the Melvin Gordon situation playing out. I’m sure this has been festering and only now becoming public (by Gordon) since the season is drawing near. I’m not one to always be on the side of the player or team or league. There are problem agents, problem teams, players, GMs, HCs, etc. The Chargers are a problem team.

Of her not doing those things? I have plenty of those.

I made it almost 2 minutes into that video. Brutal. I’m not sure what I’d have to be offered to watch the whole thing, but it would have to include several things my wife won’t do.