Kirby Jackson

This is a really good (and realistic) question. The best case scenario would be to end up at 1 and have teams fighting to get there for the QB. You take a package that only moves you a couple of picks and STILL get Bosa or Oliver. If you could do something like what the 49ers did with the Bears 2 years ago it would be good. You take the stud DL and then load up on offense. You need OL and pass catchers. Just keep taking the best guy available at those spots. Outside of Dawkins you might not have an OL or WR that will start next year.

My first call would be Bashaud Breeland. He can solve the hole at CB (maybe for now and the future). My second call would be to Matt Moore. He can come in as the vet number 2 and Peterman can be cut. The guy just can’t play in the NFL. My 3rd call would be Luke Joekel. He may be able to fill one of the those spots.

I don’t know. He can’t be worse. Bashaud Breeland was the guy that I had in mind. Again, I wasn’t looking for him to single out anyone. I might not have communicated that clearly. I just wanted something like “it starts with me” as someone else mentioned. I would have been fine with “we were thoroughly outplayed and need to get it fixed.” When you are embarrassed like that don’t patronize us. It is like when he said after the 5 INT game “Nate did some things well.” Just be honest and move on. I guess that I just lose trust and respect for someone that is willing to lie to us. I was not looking for him to throw anyone under the bus but I also wasn’t looking for him to withhold the truth. Say it was bad or embarrassing and we need to work to fix it. Fair

Oh this is fun!! I think that you are on: - Allen starts - Bodine to C, Groy to LG, Vlad to the unemployment line - I predict that NEITHER Davis nor Gaines starts at CB. My bold prediction is that a CB not currently on the roster is playing that spot. I would also fire Castillo but it won’t happen. His unit is a mess.

I guess for me 47-3 without a 1st down in the 1st half is different than 20-17. I have no issues if he says that in those situations. This wasn’t the time to hide behind the tape. Your team was utterly dominated in all aspects.

Just to be clear I’m not asking him to crush anyone publicly. Those guys mentioned were just examples. At the same time when you get buried like that you don’t need to look at the tape to figure out what happened. He could have went the route of, “we struggled in the passing game. The line committed too many penalties, there were drops and some throws that we’d like back. It wasn’t a good day.”

See above

Maybe so but managing the public is a big part of a head coaches’ job. He isn’t doing anyone favors by getting the media, and in turn the fans, worked up. When that happens, he, and his team lose the benefit of the doubt.

If those guys would have gotten 3 starts they would have been better.

This isn’t intended to be a pitchfork thread as there are already 59 of them. One thing that really, really bothered me yesterday when McDermott talked about the need to look at the tape after the game before commenting on certain things. It was clear to literally everyone that Peterman was a disaster. Phillip Gaines should change his number to ?. McDermott wasn’t being transparent at all. He might have thought that he was helping his team but he was insulting the fan base. He would have earned a lot more respect by holding himself accountable like he preaches. He talks an awful lot about accountability and then doesn’t practice it. I know I would have had a lot more respect for him if he told it like it was instead of sticking his head in the sand.

...and he stinks too

He would keep giving the merch away to the other team!!

Thought the same thing

Without revealing the specific players there are some that don’t trust him. I’d imagine that the number is rising today. McDermott has said some things to people and then acted differently. There are (and were) a few that hate(d) him. It had nothing to do with the Tyrod situation either. I think naturally that’s what people assume. He actually apologized to the team about that. It has more to do with people’s roles. He has been straight with everyone. Weren’t you smoking that just last week?

He can’t be on the roster anymore IMO. Peterman should have taken his last ever NFL snap yesterday. 5th round scrubs come and go all of the time in this league. They certainly don’t keep getting opportunities after performing worse than ANY QB EVER!! Sign Moore, cut Peterman and let’s put this nightmare behind us.

Allen is miles ahead of Peterman. If you can’t see that it’s because you spent the last 4 months touting Nate. This week is the week to go stick your head in the sand not double down!! At this point Peterman is legitimately the worst QB of all-time. He put up a stellar 0.0 QB rating yesterday. It’s okay to be wrong. Peterman sucks and it’s not up for debate.

Benjamin stinks. He’s certainly not a number 1 and can’t be back next year. That would be a waste of cap space.

I support Kaep’s right to protest. He clearly belongs on an NFL roster if Peterman is on one. The only evidence that he needs to win his case against the NFL is Peterman’s game tape. With that being said this is not the spot for him. We are turning the page to Allen. The future is starting and there is no place for Kaepernick. I would look at someone like Matt Moore though as I don’t think Peterman should get another opportunity to fail. He’s already been given way more than he has earned. Bring in Moore as the number 2.

I thought the LBs played well. The defense came around during that came. They struggle to rush the passer and Gaines should have changed his number to a target symbol. I don’t fault the defense for today. They had awful field position and a bad CB. I actually liked the way that Milano and Edmunds played.

@GunnerBill was right. He did a ton of work and provided an honest (but unpopular) opinion. He was 100% right (as usual). I don’t need to see more. That’s the difference. I didn’t need to see this. I already knew he sucked. I’m not sure he will see another chance. When you come around though you can come join us. The water is warm!!

I like Frazier. His unit just spent WAY too much time on the field and had terrible field position. If they could rush the passer they’d be a good unit. The offense killed the defense today.

Whaley was a pretty good GM IMO. He has had some offers. FWIW, he can go back to the Steelers at any point. They think very highly of him. He added talent. Whaley’s mistake was that he didn’t cross all of his “t’s” and dot all of his “I’s.” His biggest mistake as a GM was not having an out in the Dareus contract. There had to be some recourse if he was suspended (again).

I’m trying to figure out when it’s acceptable to ask all of the Petermaniacs for an apology? We said that he sucked and took heat. He sucks. Is anyone going to be bold enough to own it and admit that he is trash?

Perfectly said!!!