To be fair, I've always been an EJ hopeful. Please keep that in mind.
During the routes on air section, it is clear to me that EJ has a superior arm. He is big, powerful and was throwing it well. Cassel has a tight spiral but a noticeably weaker arm. Tyrod was average.
One of one's was another EJ win, with a couple nice throws that BB.com has posted. This was Tyrods worst session of the day. Cassel looked good as well.
As far as there team action, I felt that EJ was overwhelmed. He undoubtedly has the physical tools, but the blitz's, reads and coverages seem to impose negatively on him. For instance, the pick he through to Charles Clay was the right read, and had he lead him, would have been a 30 yard gain after escaping pressure. Instead, on the move, he left it a good five yards short, resulting in a terrible mistake.
Cassel seemed to make decent throws, but at this point, I am against starting him. He wreaks of Trent Edwards and always seemed to hit the underneath routes. He definitely has command of the offense, but it didn't appear he did his OL or running game any favors by limiting the log ball.
Tyrod to me was the worst QB of the day (I didn't watch Simms). He seemed erratic and of the mark. When I got home and heard Rex's comments about Taylor, I was shocked.
To me, EJ had the best day, but don't let that fool you (I'm trying not to). He did throw two picks and seemed to be leaving the long ball short.
Cassel was a close second, but I fear the check down, especially with the huge emphasis on the running game. If you can hit them over the top, they will load the box.
Tyrod gives you the mobile aspect, but seems to be an average arm with a below average pocket presence. Scrambling on 3 and 12 won't cut it either.
Again, I've been waiting for EJ to step up, and I truly hope he has. Is he better than last year? Physically? Yes. Mentally, what really matters, idk.
I have him on my mock 53