I think the differences in the situations the two QBs were given speak volumes. I don't want to take anything away from TTs night but...
EJ had no OL
Was often put in 2nd and long due to terrible running plays
Was both aided and hurt by penalties
Scored the only TD of the night. It concerns me TT wasn't able to convert in the RZ
I'm reading it differently. To me, it was late and under thrown. He didn't use the entire EZ as he could have. You're all right that it should have been caught, but it also could have been a better ball