Clearly a list written by someone in their mid-20s. Gilmore isn't even in the top 25 (high pick, good player, not worth huge money. What's so polarizing?), and Taylor is questionable for the top 5; in five years no one will be talking about 'oh what if we had kept Taylor'.
If we're specifically excluding OJ for his post-career issues, the other obvious #1 is Ralph.
Yup, that's a good one.