It ain't a great SB if the wrong team won, so obviously any games were the Pats*, Steelers or Cowboys won don't qualify:
#1 Giants/Pats I -- literally the second most excited I've ever been watching sports (after 1986 game 6)
#2 Giants/Pats II -- almost as good as the first time
#3 Seahawks/Pats -- ***** you Pete Carroll
#4 Falcons/Pats -- ***** you Dan Quinn
#3 Broncos/GB -- I was completely pulling for Elway, jumped out of my chair on that helicopter run
#4 SF/Cincy II -- Montana with the all-time SB drive
#5 Broncos/Panthers -- Manning deserving of #2; Newton deserving of his pouty, whiny B word press conference