I did not read the thread because of the AOLish wording... good call on that by the way.
My thoughts are this though... Da'Rick Rodgers can play special teams just as good as others WRs on the squad, and has more potential than the others in front of him. That includes Stevie...
I think TJ is expendable, trade for a 5th rd pick. Goodwin is a better version of TJ.
Robert Woods and Goodwin on the outside, and Stevie in the slot. Goaline sub Rodgers in for Goodwin, solid WRs.
It's just not worth losing that potential on waivers... and he's on the cheap.