BillsFan130

The thing is if Miami trades for him, he’s going to get a massive contract from them. Probably will be the highest paid back at around 15 mil per year. It would be cost control for this year but that’s it

If you want to say Edmunds was good, that’s fair and I would respectfully disagree. But You do know that Roger Saffold made the pro bowl last year, right? That should tell you everything you need to know about how much of a joke making the pro bowl is

Spot on about Epenasa, He drives me crazy. I am sure he will finish the season with descent stats again, but his lack of contain in the pocket on numerous occasions is inexcusable

Fair points but even if they do deliver, you’re tying up a lot of assets to a position that is very replaceable. When Henry went down in 2021, the titans rushing offence if I’m not mistaken was as effective, or at least close to being as effective without him in the lineup. I think to have a good rushing offence it’s way more important to have good scheme/good o line, opposed to investing heavy in the RB position itself

Epenasa just flys by the quarterback way too often .. 0 contain on that TD run from him

If someone can tell me: On the first drive were those both drops by Gabe? The stream I’m watching on, it’s a little hard to tell

Josh defies the rules haha. He has the arm strength to get away with throws back across the body. But ya on that specific play he was wide open for sure

Beautiful drive. That was vintage Josh. O line held up well which is great to see

Stop making sense… Haha 100 percent agree , we definitely see it the same way

100 percent agree. I’m in the camp it’s never smart for a team to give a RB a big 2nd contract. I really can’t remember that ever ending well for the player/team. (with the exception of Mccafery who is a very unique player)

That was 2021 a long time ago for nfl running back standards. Colts o line was arguably the best in football that year as well. Dolphins o line is a mess. Let them Pay an injury prone RB 14-15 mil a year behind a crap o line

I hope Miami trades for him. Let them spend their draft picks and tie up huge dollars to an injury prone running back

I still think if the bills looked good last week, the starters wouldn’t be playing this Saturday. Last year Bills starters didn’t play the 3rd game, and if you recall they looked really crisp in that 2nd pre season game

You aren't wrong- I just can't see the Bills cutting Shakir though as he showed flashes and is cost control for the next 3 years. I think it is between Isabella and Shorter. Ideal scenario would be for Shorter to be placed in IR with a "mysterious injury"- That way you can keep both of them

This is true. But he also said that Spencer brown looked very vulnerable the whole time he was in and he had big concerns

Joe Marino broke down his game film and said it was not good. Which makes sense as that’s what I saw when watching live. And for Joe to say that says a lot, as he’s been the biggest Spencer brown homer

Read my posts again.

I was asking you a legit question. That’s what makes playing tackle so damn hard. You can’t play “good” and have 2-4 bad mistakes a game. Which is exactly my point Thats how you lose games and that’s how you get your QB killed. (See last year how Josh injured his elbow against the jets)

Lol ok so let’s average it out. 1 hold/sack a quarter. Let’s say he lets up a combination of 3 sacks/holds for a game. Is that considered a good game for you?

As a tackle you can’t have one bad mistake a quarter. That’s my point. It’s not confirmation bias

I really don’t understand. Brown has been underwhelming the first 2 years and got beat bad by a backup defensive end on 1 rep in the 1st quarter. Do you disagree with any of that?

I agree Dawkins looked worse. My point what I’m trying to say though is if you’re a tackle and let 1-2 bad plays in a game, those are game changing negative plays. And getting crushed by a backup DE in just one quarter does nothing to elevate my confidence in Spencer brown

I know. But when has Spencer brown ever shown consistency in his career? Yes one bad play in a quarter against a backup. He doesn’t get the benefit of the doubt. I am not automatically going to write him off, but he’s a major concern at a premium position as of now

On Spencer brown- on his holding penalty, he got absolutely abused by a backup DE. 1-2 negative plays is all it takes for a tackle to have a bad game, and Brown seemed to have 1-2 bad plays in the first quarter alone.

It would be ideal and it’s a good thought, but put yourself in another GMs shoes . Would you trade a young tackle with upside for basham and shorter? No way I would