BillsFan130

Ok “when he’s on his game” doesn’t really answer the question though. So in a 17 game season averaging out the highs and lows, where do you rank him roughly?

Every time I’ve seen your posts, you seem to rip on Josh. You even somewhat excused the defensive performance on Sunday saying the eagles had a lot of short fields and put a lot of blame on Josh for that one INT. (Even though he was the best player in football that week) So my question to you is: Do you not think he’s a good QB and where do you rank him in terms of QB? I just don’t get where you’re going with this constant crusade on Josh so I’m genuinely curious lol

Here’s where you’re right and here’s where I believe you’re a bit off. yes they care about results primarily, that’s where you’re right. however: No one wants to be thrown under the bus. And a leader should never do that to his coaches/players. Under any circumstance example: Joe Brady saying “it’s not Josh’s fault or gabes fault, it’s mine”. That is taking ownership. When you say “it starts with me” and then basically blame everyone but yourself essentially, that’s not taking ownership. That’s deflection. Once again and I don’t say this to sound condescending in anyway. I highly recommend you read extreme ownership by Jocko and you’ll understand my issues with McDermott in his post game presses

“Starts with me”. Then goes on to blame everyone else but himself basically . You don’t do that as a leader/coach “Extreme ownership “ by Jocko. if you haven’t read that, highly recommended. That’s how a leader should lead.

Ok I’ll give him that as he did take some responsibility there. Thats extremely rare from him though and yes I’ve heard him speak many times after a loss. He passive aggressively throws players and coaches under the bus all the time . ”i felt like we scored too fast there” against Denver. Like that’s a disgraceful thing to say as a “leader” especially when his idiotic defensive play calling and the special teams gaf (which as the head coach he’s ultimately responsible for) cost them the game.

Yep. I don’t know why people get caught up so much in the INTs. Does he have to limit them at times? For sure. But we see how ordinary he is when “Josh “ isnt allowed to be “Josh” Got to take some bad with the greatness

When has McDermott ever taken ownership after a loss in the last two years? he will either say “we didn’t execute “. Or even something as ridiculous as blaming his offensive coordinator for scoring too fast at the end of the broncos game lol

Joe Marino said against the eagles that the bills basically ran the same defence all game long. The eagles adjusted in the 3rd quarter, and McDermott had no counter off the eagles adjustment (again according to Joe Marino)

His reasoning was basically because the rain which is ridiculous makes absolutely no sense because up to that point, the bills had like 460 Yards of offence, only one sack and one turnover in about 88 plays. The guy has absolutely no feel for the game

A coach taking ownership. Not used to hearing that from our head coach I applause Joe Brady for that

He passive aggressively throws his players and coaches under the bus all the time . He never says “it’s my fault “. listen to a Dan Campbell post game press after a loss compared to MCD. MCD never takes any ownership and that is a sign of a terrible leader

1. 13 seconds 2. Houston playoff game 3. This loss 4. Vikings game last year 5. Hail murray game there are so many other horrible ones as well lol

Vikings went wayyy too conservative when they had the ball last possession. Ran it twice . if they got one first down, it would have been essentially over

Fields ain’t the dude

Yep. But that’s on Bass, not McDermott

McDermott made a lot of awful decisions, but I don’t think that was one of them. Your 5 million dollar kicker simply just has to make that kick.

The Vikings and bears are basically the bills with less talent. Two dumb teams

Dobbs is awful tonight. Too bad as he’s an easy guy to go for

To be honest I don’t think you’re wrong. I disagree on the Frazier part as I don’t think he will be back. But I got a weird feeling that MCD is going to be back. (Although he absolutely should not be)

Yep. A leader should never deflect blame to others. The man needs to read “extreme Ownership “ by Jocko and learn a thing or 10

The only thing ok about that would be Brady as the OC. MCD back along with his conservative buddy Frazier would be an absolute nightmare scenario IMO

Not over but not looking good. I see them losing to the chiefs. Dallas? 50/50 Chargers, winnable game Pats- SHOULD win Miami- who knows how much they have to play for as they may have a seed locked up

Haha romo is such a bills/josh fan. I kind of like it but it was so obvious he wanted the bills to win yesterday lol

For sure- I was more mentioning game of the year candidate losses. But ya those ones you listed definitely fall under the inexplicable loss category including a lot more over the years

Under McDermott? Houston playoff game, Hail Mary against Arizona, 13 seconds, Vikings game, this one. Those were probably all game of the year candidates (maybe not the Texans game) and the bills lost every single one lol. That doesn’t even include all the other inexplicable close losses