Please, man. It's not like Manning didn't get his shots. He took those shots and was picked twice. I'm not really sure what "logic" you are referring to, nor am I sure what you're trying to argue.
I do feel like this has been a good season overall, with reasons for optimism. As long as we re-sign our key free agents on the defense, I like our chances next year. But we are in the present and I still want wins!