If I HAD to choose, it'd be McCoy. I think he could be a decent game manager. Gabbert is just filth. If you watch his college tape, he's a mess in the pocket and not very accurate at all. Horrible mechanics and footwork. Crazy where he was drafted. Just a side note, how did Rodgers not get drafted higher in the 2005 draft. Watch his tape, he does EVERYTHING well. I'm just surprised he wasn't touted as a Luck or Manning type prospect.