K D

1. Tyrod Oh wait...

That is certainly the scouts point of view. From a QB's point of view he looks sloppy. Everything he does is pretty much what they tell you not to do. Much like the RB throwing in my story, it works and it gets the job done for the most part but it's not pretty. It could cause big issues at the next level. His throwing motion is not repeatable. It's anyone's guess what is going to happen from play to play. You want your QB to be so robot like that it's almost boring. Think of Brady passing the ball down the field. Nothing exciting about it. 10 yards here, 15 there, right down the field to win the game. That is the type of passer Rosen is. Darnold, it's anyone's guess what is going to happen from play to play. It's exciting to watch but it doesn't have to be. It should be so mechanical that it's boring. If both were on my team Rosen would be my starter.

I do agree with him that he never tried to gain a competitive advantage in any way

I just watched Darnold and Rosen film back to back today. It's not even close. Rosen is so far superior it's a joke that this is even a discussion. Darnold dances around and jump passes it to get it in the playmakers hands. It's effective but it's not something you see at the NFL level. His footwork is horrible, he's falling away from the throw, all of his momentum is going backwards instead of stepping into the throw. It works on those short quick passes in that offense because it's basically a long handoff, just trying to get it into the receiver's hands to let them run with it. You never see him stand tall in the pocket and deliver a strike. If anything he will do that while scrambling or again while falling away from the pressure. I don't know if he lacks the arm strength on some of these throws or if it's just because he's falling backwards and doesn't have the momentum behind his throw because of his poor mechanics. Josh Rosen is next level. On multiple throws he is set up to deliver the throw to a receiver but at the last second checks it down mid throw. You can see him going through the progression and he changes his release at the last second to throw it underneath. Because of his mechanics he can do that without resetting his feet. It's absolutely brilliant to see. Perfect base, good footwork in the pocket, momentum going forward, nice follow through. Just so impressive. Ask any QB to watch the film and it's not even a contest between these guys. So what I think is happening is there's too many cooks in the kitchen. A scout watches the film and sees Darnold as a solid "football player" who is big and strong and effective. He can escape pressure and get the ball to the playmaker. But it's soooo ugly to watch. It's not what you are taught to do at all. We used to have a RB in high school that would do a sweep play with the option to throw and he would basically flip the ball to the wr. He wouldn't even try and grip the ball and throw a spiral he would just kind of flop the ball out there. That's what Darnold reminds me of. No mechanics. Any scout that has Darnold rated high is because they are not a QB, don't understand the position, and do not know what proper mechanics look like. Ask any QB to watch the tape and it would be unanimous. Rosen is the best QB in this draft.

I vote for Derby Dan as my new favorite source

Big day today in the city of angels. The Buffalo bills are on the west coast! Decisions to be made...

Is anyone else surprised that the least likely to bust is Mayfield?

You are reaching. A believable rumor would be someone like Sal Capaccio saying he heard something. Not some dumb kid on Twitter. You can search Twitter right now and find 100 rumors like this

Oh dear. Some kid having fun online. Let me know when someone reputable tweets something. There's so much nonsense out there, this hardly needed it's own thread

The one player is who I thought but it's a lot closer than I thought it would be. Interesting stuff

No they didnt. Those were tackling dummies for training camp. I want a real QB

not a McBeane guy. Jerry Jones literally had people on staff whose only job it was to keep Dez out of trouble. ain't happening

i'm trying not to respond, i don't want to influence the voting. i'll just say that i think the voting so far is very interesting and not what i expected!

hahahaha sound the alarm...we have a HOT TAKE!!!!!!!!

also hates the Patriots

I think that is overthinking it. Take the best player. I remember Drew Brees was available and nobody wanted him because he had shoulder concerns. Only the Saints and Dolphins were interested. Thank god he didn't go to the Dolphins. You can't predict injuries. Every football player will get injured at some point. It's just part of the game. Maybe Rosen had concussions in college but Darnold likes to run and maybe he has a career ending injury week 1. You never know

Which top QB is most likely to BUST?

Rosen has been a better prospect than Goff and Darnold his entire life. he was the Chosen Rosen for a reason, top recruit in the country, certainly best player in CA

I also read that the team was moving to Hamilton because the Pegula's can't own 2 pro teams in the same city

QB

I also agree that the Bills should probably take one of the good QB's. taking a bad QB would not be beneficial

WHAT IF... Browns want Jackson. He's the ideal QB to pair with Tyrod. They take Barkley or Chubb at 1, trade 4 with Buffalo and get a ton of picks, take Jackson at 12, use extra draft capital to trade up from 22 and take another impact player like one of the top CB or S. Could get their QB plus 3 other 1st round picks if they play their cards right

I believe the McBeane's think Josh Allen can be like Cam Newton. They fail to realize that Cam was so highly recruited that they were offering his services to the highest bidder and Auburn may or may not have paid a fortune to get him. Nobody wanted Josh Allen, 1 D1 scholarship offer, he played the games and still stunk, but....he's tall and athletic with a strong arm! he's Cam Newton! Minus the Heisman trophy and National Championship or really any kind of success at all. But otherwise EXACTLY THE SAME!

my bold NFL draft prediction...is that these hats will be in the clearance bin for $4.99 in about 3 weeks