Rocky Landing

Yes, but doesn't every thread turn into a Tyrod thread?

I like the premise of this poll, but I declined to vote because the options are too specific. I probably would have gone for option B, with D being a close second, except that I think there are other trade scenarios available to us that I would feel better about. I also wouldn't mind us staying put, but don't necessarily agree with the draft choices.

I would assume that the FO, or any QB candidate, FA or draftee, would not spend a lot of time analyzing the fan's opinions. It would be a pointless endeavor, and I would assume that Buffalo is not alone in the unhinged fervency its fan base adopts when a section of that fan base draws its ironclad conclusions about a QB.

My point is that we have enough draft capital to trade up this year into the top 5 without mortgaging the future the way we did for Watson. We're not likely to have that opportunity in 2019.

Despite the wishes of some around here, we didn't tank this year. We're not going to tank next year, either. In this draft, we have more draft capital than I can ever remember having. There are at least seven teams ahead of us in the draft who need a QB. If there was a year to trade up for a QB, this is it. Otherwise, do we spend the the next decade rolling the dice on the likes of EJ Manuel, or Nate Peterman hoping for a "diamond in the rough?" I hope not.

What if Shady were part of a package to trade up with the Browns, who also need a running back? Browns draft 1st and 4th. If we wait until 21st, who will be left?

Are the Bills working on a Tre White/Zay Jones hybrid in a lab somewhere? 'Cuz that would be cool!

I'm slightly surprised that, as of this post, almost 20% of respondents would have preferred we miss the playoffs. I would have guessed closer to 10%.

As I read this, I wonder if, along with monetary incentives, Kraft* didn't express a desire for McDaniels* to succeed Bellichick* upon his retirement, which one would assume would coincide with Brady's* retirement?

It's cheaper than that Bills @ Chargers game I spent good money to see! EDIT: And I'll bet the beer is cheaper, too!

When asked about the incident, afterwards:

I know they showed the replay about a dozen too many times, but the fact that Brady* dropped the pass on that trick play, and then Foles smoked them for a TD on, essentially, the exact same play is one of the greatest moments of this miserable year so far.

And Jim Schwarz

Great play

Every year, I sign the petition to get Weird Al Yankovic to host the halftime show. Every year is a disappointment.

Fred is absolutely one of my all time favorite players. I would love to see a roast of him by his friends and colleagues so that I could learn more about his personality, relationships, hang-ups, and whatever else those who know him well would want to poke fun at. I watched the Roast of Justin Beiber, and actually developed a shred of respect for him. I don't see any downside to a FredEX roast.

This discussion would be a lot more interesting if it weren't so utterly academic for Bills fans.

Good. The guy is a notorious, bullying A-hole. He represents the wrong process.

I would now suspect that no actions will be taken regarding the QB position until we have a new OC.

What makes you think that Smith will be cheaper than Cousins?

Not this again...

1) Draft a QB with our first pick. If there is a reasonable option for trading up to get Rosen, or Darnold, then do it, but only within reason (which seems unlikely). Trading up for Allen might be more doable, but only for a fair price. In defense of my position: I'm far from a draft expert. But, there does seem to consensus that the QB class is deep, and that Rosen, and Darnold are the top of the class. It's exciting to have so many draft picks, and I'd hate to see too many of them sold off for a single pick. 2) Unless we get a decent trade offer, Keep Taylor. If our rookie QB is ready to start in September, fine- start the rook. Otherwise, start Taylor until the rook is ready. Like Keenum and Goff in LA. In defense of my position: If we draft a rookie QB, it only makes sense to have a vet presence. Despite the hatred of Taylor by about 25% of this board, and the general dissatisfaction of him by another significant percentage, the actual offense does not seem to feel this way. If there is a better option at vet, I'd love to hear it. But, Taylor knows the team, and the team respects him. He is, by all accounts, a consummate professional, leader, and effective communicator. And, he's under contract. 3) Spend resources in the draft, and free agency on improving the O-line. Make whomever is behind center safe for once. In defense of my position: Let's be real-- the right side has been a problem for as long as Taylor has been under center, and before. IMO, Taylor made our line look better than it was with his athleticism. Even his die-hard haters will admit that he can break tackles exceptionally well. That shouldn't be such a requisite for a QB. 4) Spend resources in the draft, and free agency on improving the WR corps. (I haven't generally been a fan of drafting for need vs. drafting BPA, but maybe this year we should weigh need a little heavier?) In defense of my position: I believe that we have enough draft picks to give need more weight, and our WR corps has got to be one of the worst in the league. 5) If they're going keep three QBs, keep Webb, and drop Peterman like a bad habit. In defense of my position: I paid good money for two fine seats at the Stubhub Center for that Cargers game, and I don't think I will ever forgive Late Nate Peterman.

Draft a QB early and keep Tyrod. If (and only if) the rookie is ready by week one, great. If not, play Tyrod until he is. (EDIT: And save further embarrassment: cut Peterman.)

It's sadly not surprising that the CoTH has taken this thread as another opportunity to bash Tyrod. (Is there a punchbowl you're not willing to piss in?) Personally, I hope to see him in a Bills uni next season. I hope we draft a QB in the 1st, and keep Tyrod as the vet mentor/early-season starter.