No Lamar requires it to be effective as he's not an above average passer. I agree they different runners, Lamar is a running QB like Vick was and Josh is a QB who runs like Elway was. To me totally different players.
No Lamar sucks because he has had 45 TD passes (including tonight) the last 3 years whereas Josh has had 90 and some feel they should be called equals.
If you're going to put Lamar at the top tier he should be compared to Josh, Mahomes and Burrow to me the best 3 in the game. Lamar is maybe top 10 but most want to say top 5. I mean 2 weeks ago people felt he was a MVP candidate.
And yet None of their WRa have a game with 100 yards receiving yards this year and Lamar averaging 1 TD passes per game and 30-40 or so more yards passing per game than last year.