We disagree, especially between him and Manning. I hate going to different eras and I think Montana was one of the clutch QB in history.
But even if I wasn't a Pats fan I lean towards Brady over Manning because he was clutch in the playoffs.. And it doesn't matter if it was a FG to win it, it is something Manning never was able to do in a playoff game, never mind the SB. Manning was the greatest Reg season QB but when the games started to matter he was average. I take Brady,Montana before him. But again we don't have to agree what makes life great is disagreeing and calmly talking why we disagree.