This trade wouldn't have made sense 2 days ago, but post Lamar Miller injury... yes
Shady's contract is huge, but he is a one year rental - which they need
Zay fills the WR void
3rd round pick for someone who could walk away? take it
Now from our end we lose our starting RB but we have others to make up for it. Zay was climbing down the depth chart, but he still had potential to do great things, so we will never be able to see his true potential. 3rd round pick? High, but at least we keep our 1 and 2. But...
We add Clowney to our already potent defense. These type of additions will literally make us the Chicago Bears of the AFC.
My vote: TRADE