-
Posts
2,921 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by mjt328
-
Josh Allen Running Style Versus Cam Newton
mjt328 replied to TroutDog's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Agree with this statement completely. Josh Allen's running ability is deadly in the Red Zone and on 3rd Down. That is something you never want to take away, because that is his greatest advantage over other Quarterbacks in the NFL. Using him like a Running Back at other points of the game, I'm definitely not a huge fan of. You want to keep your QB from getting injured. -
Opinions on a hypothetical trade
mjt328 replied to offsides#76FredSmerlas's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Injuries are a real thing. AJ Green missed a big chunk of 2016, half of 2018 and all of 2019. He's had problems with his hamstring, his toe, his ankle - all of which are extremely important to a WR. In his prime, Green was among the best WRs in the league. Today, he's basically a long-shot to ever get meaningful snaps on a football field again. John Brown isn't much younger, but he's healthy. Which makes all the difference in the world. -
If he was targeting an O-Lineman, that rules out Round 2. We picked at 54 and the last OL player to go before us was Robert Hunt at 39. Beane stated they were targeting Zack Moss the entire time in Round 3, and actually tried to move-up for him. Also ruled out. Now Beane says he was discussing the trade with an NFC General Manager. He also states the pick was about 3-4 spots above ours. In Round 4, we picked at 128. OT Charlie Heck went only two picks before us. So if we were targeting him, that would mean we were discussing a trade up one spot with Philly. This doesn't fit. However, Detroit took OG Logan Stenberg 7 picks before us. And Chicago owned pick 125 (eventually traded to the Jets). This is a fit. In Round 5, there are several fits. We picked at 167. There are several NFC teams between us and when OC Nick Harris was picked at 160. It's also worth noting that Beane "wasn't planning" on targeting a QB this weekend, and picked Jake Fromm simply because of value on the board. This also suggests he was targeting something else, but it fell through. There are also fits in Round 6. We picked at 188. There were a handful of OL players picked in the early 180s (Hakeem Adeniji, Netane Muti and Michael Onwenu). There are also a group of NFC GMs in-between, including our counterpart the Panthers at 184. We ended up taking a kicker at that pick. Later in the round, OT Blake Brandel went a few picks before us. With the Vikings sitting in-between. Round 7 has Dustin Woodard going nine spots before us, with a handful of NFC teams in-between. So by process of elimination, I believe the player Beane was targeting is among this list: OG Logan Stenberg OC Nick Harris OT Hakeem Adeniji OG Netane Muti OG Michael Onwenu OT Blake Brandel OC Dustin Woodard
-
No football til mid October??? -Carucci
mjt328 replied to Chandler#81's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
I'm really starting to question the "long-game" with this whole COVID-19 thing. Scientifically, there are only two ways to get something like this under control. The option that everybody would LIKE to see is a vaccine, which would obviously cause the least amount of sickness and death. Unfortunately, all medical experts say a vaccine isn't coming until 2021 at the very earliest. And there is no guarantee a vaccine will EVER be developed for this particular coronavirus. It's not something that people want to hear. But sadly it's the truth. So unless we are going to stop the world indefinitely (and possibly permanently), that leaves one option. The same way mankind has dealt with viruses, diseases and epidemics for the entire time they have been on this planet. And that is by Herd Immunity. Meaning that lots of people get sick. Some die. The majority recover and develop antibodies to keep the sickness from spreading. Life goes back to normal. There isn't ONE legitimate scientist that believes we can quarantine or social distance this thing into going away. The purpose of the lockdowns were always to SLOW the spread, so that we didn't overwhelm the hospitals and medical system. By having people avoid getting the virus, we are simply delaying the inevitable. Whether we open things back up in May, June, July, August, September or sometime in 2021, the virus will still be around and there will be a spike of new cases. It won't be until a significant portion of the population gets this and recovers, that things will truly be under control. Honestly, the smartest thing we can do is release the people who are young, healthy and face the lowest risk of death from COVID-19. Let them go back to work and be exposed to this thing. Keep the older population and those with pre-existing conditions in isolation, wearing masks and away from those who are out in the world. There will be a second wave, and there will be some people who die. But within 2-3 months, immunity will spread and this thing will be under control. -
Patriots got a little weaker - James Devlin retires
mjt328 replied to CorkScrewHill's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
I honestly don't know why ANYONE is scared of this team. If anybody else was going into camp with Brian Hoyer and Jarrett Stidham at the top of their QB depth chart, they would be a laughing stock. Not to mention, they have done absolutely nothing to upgrade their offensive skill positions (which were pretty bad last season). Because it's Bill Belichick, everyone assumes he just knows something everyone else doesn't. -
RD 2, Pick 54: DE AJ Epenesa, University of Iowa
mjt328 replied to SDS's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Pretty much every NFL team puts draft prospects into tiers. Not a strict ranking of #1-300. The idea of BPA is that you never drop-down a tier, JUST so you can address a need. It's NOT that you always take your 105th ranked player over your 106th ranked player. Early in the draft, most GMs are going to have very strict separations in those tiers. For instance, Chase Young may be in a tier all of his own. A team going BPA would say, "Edge Rusher isn't my biggest need, but I'm drafting Young anyway because he's clearly the best player available." A team that doesn't go BPA may decide to take Jeff Okudah instead, because he really needs a cornerback. Or one of the top O-Line prospects, because the team struggled with blocking last year. Obviously as the draft goes on, teams won't have prospects ranked so strictly. By the 5th-6th-7th Round, you aren't talking about generational talents. You are talking about special teams players, practice squad developmental guys, and roster long-shots. Instead of 2-3 guys in a tier, a GM may have 10-20 guys ranked similarly. Which allows for more flexibility in filling specific roster spots. Beane is usually a BPA guy. But this weekend, he admitted that by the end of Day 3, he wasn't taking guys at the top of his board. He was taking positions that actually had a chance to make our roster. -
RD 2, Pick 54: DE AJ Epenesa, University of Iowa
mjt328 replied to SDS's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Which is obviously the only reason he slipped into the 2nd Round. Before the Combine, most places had him ranked as the #2 defensive end behind Chase Young. In January/early February, it was rare to find a mock with him lasting past the Top 15. His supposed lack of speed/athleticism was accounted for in the latest rankings. He was still a Top 30 player and late first-rounder on most of the sites that I saw. At the end of the day, the only thing that matters is how good he turns out. We won't know that for 2-4 years. To grade a draft today, we can only look at: a) The projections being done by so-called experts b) Whether a GM was able to get maximum value out of that pick, rather than reach early for a player c) How well the team addressed roster needs Based on these three standards, Brandon Beane was able to get a 1st Round prospect about 25-30 spots later than he was expected to go. It also addressed one of the team's biggest future question-marks, since both current starters are over 30 years old. -
The Bills drafted two guys last year (Dawson Knox and Tommy Sweeney), and really like both. They also signed Tyler Kroft, and watched him battle injuries the entire season. They obviously like him as well. This was also a very crappy year for Tight Ends in the draft. Cole Kmet was the highest ranked, and I think the Bears took him a round too early.
-
RD 2, Pick 54: DE AJ Epenesa, University of Iowa
mjt328 replied to SDS's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Wow. I haven't been on the message boards much this weekend, and was absolutely shocked that some Bills fans are upset with this pick. Defensive End was among our Top 2-3 biggest areas for improvement (I wouldn't really say we had huge needs anywhere). And based on the rankings by most experts, this was a massive steal. For some perspective, here are where some of the main sports sites ranked AJ Epenesa before the draft: NFL.Com: #45th Overall ESPN: #23rd Overall Fox Sports: #31st Overall CBS Sports: #34th Overall NBC Sports: #28th Overall Pro Football Focus: #20th Overall The Draft Network: #27th Overall Sports Illustrated: #24th Overall Sporting News: #20th Overall Draftek: #23rd Overall Averaging these 10 sites, Epenesa was around the 27th-28th ranked prospect in the entire draft. We got him at #54. -
2020 NFL Draft Round 2 and 3 Discussion.
mjt328 replied to MAJBobby's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Always a bunch of teams that reach, or have players valued differently. There will be some really good players available to the Bills. -
Right now, the Bills defense would probably look like this, depending on the package: - AJ Klein starting at SLB in base 4-3 looks - Taron Johnson starting at NCB in pure nickel defense against 3 wide receivers - Siran Neal starting at NCB in the big nickel From what I understand (from those who studied Carolina's old defensive packages), Sean McDermott actually prefers to go with the Big Nickel formation more often. We just haven't had an exact fit in his first 3 years here. The recent interest in Kyle Dugger and Jeremy Chinn is causing several to connect the dots.
-
Is it a HUGE NEED. Absolutely not. But in all honesty, we don't have ANY really big needs this year. Any position we draft is going to be playing a limited number of snaps as a rookie. Lots of people want a Running Back. Whoever we draft is going to splitting carries with Devin Singletary. Lots of people want a Wide Receiver. A draftee would be #4 at best behind Stefon Diggs, John Brown and Cole Beasley. Lots of people want a Defensive End. A rookie would rotate behind Jerry Hughes, Mario Addison and Quinton Jefferson. Lots of people want a Cornerback. We already have a competition of Josh Norman, Levi Wallace and EJ Gaines opposite Tre White. Our current Big Nickel is usually Siran Neal, who is better suited as a pure backup Safety. Upgrading Neal would give us more ability to cover TEs, while not sacrificing run support. It's another chess piece for our coaching staff.
-
Nothing is more important than helping Allen right now
mjt328 replied to Tesla03's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Do you ever notice how teams like Baltimore sit there in the 20s every draft, and watch highly rated players (this year it was linebacker Patrick Queen) just fall into their laps? The reason why? Because they usually go into the draft without any glaring needs. I've been waiting SO LONG for the Bills to reach this point. Where they aren't forced to target a WR or a CB or an OT, and they can just let the talent drop to them. There are places on the roster that could use better depth, but nothing glaring that we need to freak-out if they go somewhere else. -
2020 NFL Draft: Round 1 discussion
mjt328 replied to YoloinOhio's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
First Round completed. Lots of picks before the Bills go. Some interesting names still on the board, and I wouldn't be surprised to see us trade up into the 40s. The Top 3 running backs (Swift, Taylor, Dobbins) are all still available. Three potential 1st Round edge rushers (Epenesa, Gross-Matos, Baun) are still there There were big runs on WR, CB and OT. But there are still some solid names left, who were considered late 1st/early 2nd talents. Higgins, Shenault, Mims, Pittman at WR, Jones at OT, Diggs, Fulton and Johnson at CB. Another popular choice is Safety, and somehow none have been picked yet. McKinney was considered a Top 20 pick. Delpit was not far behind. If the Bills go here, I think they are looking at a specific kind of fit for the defense however. -
Which 6-8 players/positions will the Bills pay big money to?
mjt328 replied to Logic's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Your list is good, although I don't know if Matt Milano will command $10 million per. The good news is, we can stagger these contracts. We won't need to pay everyone big money at the same time. Dion Dawkins and Matt Milano become free agents next year Tre White becomes a free agent in 2022 Josh Allen and Tremaine Edmunds in 2023 Ed Oliver not until 2024 Starting next season, I think the Bills strategy will shift towards building almost entirely through the draft and then re-signing their own. Veteran additions will be reasonable, and not big money. By the time Oliver is needing a new contract, guys like Mitch Morse and Stefon Diggs will be in their early 30's and should require less investment to keep on the roster. -
The 2014 WR Class was the best I could remember, up until this point. Everybody knew that class was going to be fantastic, and for the most part (unless you traded up to #4 to take Sammy Watkins...) it didn't disappoint. Personally, I think this class is stronger at the very top. The 2014 class was a little bit better in the back-half of the 1st/early 2nd. They look to be about the same in the late 2nd Round and early 3rd. This class has more potential on Day 3. If those two classes were merged and re-drafted (based purely on their draft ranking out of college), I think the 1st Round prospects would go something like this: CeeDee Lamb Jerry Jeudy Sammy Watkins Henry Ruggs Mike Evans Odell Beckham Brandin Cooks Kelvin Benjamin Tee Higgins I don't think the Bills consider any trade-ups until a player they covet is withing striking distance (meaning 10 or less picks), and they are scared he will not fall. I'm fully expecting them to move around on Friday and Saturday, but they won't be making huge jumps.
-
This WR class is ridiculously deep. And any scout saying different is blowing smoke. There are two elite prospects who would go Top 5-10 in almost any class: Jerry Jeudy and CeeDee Lamb. Then you have one borderline elite guy, who is sure-shot First Round in Henry Ruggs. After that, you have about 10-12 guys who would deserve 1st Round consideration in almost any year. Many of these guys are getting extra scrutiny and will be pushed down, simply because there are a multitude of other options for WR-needy teams: Laviska Shenault, Tee Higgins, Jalen Reagor, Justin Jefferson, Brandon Aiyuk, KJ Hamler, Michael Pittman, Denzel Mims, Bryan Edwards, Chase Claypool. And then you have dozens of potential sleeper guys, who could slip to Day 3 and be impact starters in the NFL. Van Jefferson, Donovan Peoples-Jones, Tyler Johnson, Antonio Gandy-Golden, Gabriel Davis, etc. I've been following the draft for 30+ years, and I've never seen a class with this much potential.
-
Any chance Tua lands in New England?
mjt328 replied to Coach Tuesday's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Dolphins, Chargers, Panthers, Jaguars, Raiders All these teams pick at least once (a couple pick twice) before the Patriots are on board. Anything is possible, but the Patriots would probably need to package multiple 1st Rounders from future years to get high enough. -
Which running back do you hope the Bills draft and why?
mjt328 replied to Logic's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
The Running Back we select needs to compliment Devin Singletary. Which means he should be good in areas that Singletary isn't. Where Singletary is shifty, the new guy should be strong, powerful and good running between the tackles. He must be great at ball security. Someone we can use in goal line situations, and grinding out the clock in the 4th Quarter. At the same time, I don't want someone that is one-dimensional and cannot catch the ball. The defense should not be able to key on run vs. pass based on who is in the game. -
I don't believe Brandon Beane is targeting any specific position at this point. Everything is going to depend on how the rest of the draft falls, which is something even he can't know for sure. He's filled the roster to the point that nothing is a pressing need. Even the positions that Bills fans are hotly debating about (RB, OL, DE, CB) have solid starters already in place. Nobody we draft will immediately step into a starting role, and it's very possible they will be waiting until least 2021 before a starting opportunity even arises. In my opinion, we could literally go anywhere with the pick, outside of QB or Kicker. Sitting at #54, Beane admitted that he probably isn't going to trade back into the 1st Round. Which makes sense, because it would certainly require next year's 1st Rounder to move up over 25-30 spots. It's a very pricey move, and there just isn't anything we need bad enough to do that. However, we do know that Beane's draft board puts players into tiers and he likes moving around to get players he wants. If he sees a drop-off in quality coming and needs to jump 5-6 spots, I could still see us trading up a couple slots.
-
I always go with the eye test first. Stats can often be misleading, and don't always account for game situations. For example, I recall the Bills defensive team from around 2003-2004 (Takeo Spikes, London Fletcher, etc.). By all accounts, they were pretty good in most statistical categories. But I feel like that unit was fairly overrated, because they always choked in key situations. When it counted, they could never make the 3rd Down/4th Quarter stop. On the flip-side, I think our defense from 2017-2018 was probably better than stats showed. They were always being put into bad field position, due to turnovers and an offense that was constantly going 3-Out. But if you are going to compare stats, the best one to start with is definitely points allowed. Especially when you consider that our defense is specifically designed to be "bend, but don't break." The second stat is probably yards per attempt (total yards allowed means virtually nothing). The third is probably turnovers.
-
This Years Draft: Can a Team Gain An Advantage Digitally?
mjt328 replied to TroutDog's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
With technology like Zoom, it sounds like team personnel will be able to communicate the same as normal. The GM, coaches and scouts will still be able to talk about what is going on. They just won't technically be in the same room. The process of looking at draft boards, calling other teams with trade offers, actually making picks will pretty much be the same. I think all of this will work out fine. The biggest change in this year's draft process is the inability to meet with prospects. I think this will cause many "red flag" prospects (whether through injury or character) to drop farther than normal. Team doctors can't do their due diligence on injuries, which makes the risk higher. Coaches can't sit-down with prospects and get a feel for their knowledge and fit. This is where some creative GMs may find an advantage. -
SI Article: forget about sports this year
mjt328 replied to PromoTheRobot's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
We don't know for sure if doctors will ever come up with a vaccine. And even if they do, it will be at least 2021 before they can complete full testing/clinical trials and be confident it doesn't cause disastrous side-effects. If people are planning to wait for a vaccine before they are willing to re-open society, then a lot of these things we love are going to disappear permanently. And professional sports are not exempt from that. Even billionaires don't have an infinite amount of money to just sit on the sidelines without income for 12-18 months. I was reading yesterday that Disney is losing $20-30 million PER DAY by having their parks closed. Many of these NFL owners are taking huge losses on multiple areas of their business. Listening to health experts, there are multiple ways (even without a vaccine) that we can gradually work our way back into normalcy. This includes getting back to large public gatherings like sports. One is by offering extensive testing, which can identify who has the virus currently (so they can be quarantined faster) and who has already recovered from it. Once a person has recovered, they are immune and can be released to operate as normal without being a risk of getting infected again or being a carrier and infecting another person. This is called herd immunity. It's very likely that MANY people have already had this and didn't even know. As you can imagine, coming up with 328 million tests for every individual in the country is a very tall task. So right now, the tests are being prioritized for those showing serious symptoms. But as time goes along, it's more likely we can achieve the ability to test most, if not all Americans. Second is by discovering medicines, drugs and treatments for the virus. This will not take anywhere near as long as a vaccine, especially if something is found among currently FDA-approved drugs. There are already multiple treatments (specifically those currently used to treat Malaria and Ebola) which are already being prescribed by doctors for critically-ill patients and proving to be very effective against this virus. Third is by making adjustments to our practices at large gatherings. Requiring people to wear masks. Taking temperatures at the door/gate. Taking extra steps to sanitize. Etc. -
Interesting Player Starting to Slide
mjt328 replied to Madd Charlie's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Agreed. If Laviska Shenault becomes a really good WR, then all the other stuff is just a bonus. My thing is that if you ONLY look at his receiving skills, there are probably a dozen (or more) guys in this class who have greater potential at the WR position. Jerry Jeudy, CeeDee Lamb, Henry Ruggs, Tee Higgins, Jalen Reagor, Justin Jefferson, Brandon Aiyuk, K.J. Hamler, Michael Pittman, Denzel Mims, Bryan Edwards, Chase Claypool, etc. And then if you look at Shenault ONLY as a running back, he's probably not even in the Top 20. Looking at the Bills roster, I don't see Shenault displacing our Top 3 receivers anytime soon. And if you are looking for contributions in the running game from a 2nd Round Pick, we would certainly get more production our of a pure RB like Jonathan Taylor, J.K. Dobbins, Clyde Edwards-Helaire, Zack Moss, etc. Which ultimately means Shenault's most effective role would be displacing Isaiah McKenzie and Andre Roberts on the depth chart. Not exactly something I'm looking for before the 4th Round. -
Listening to the doctors and medical "experts" talk about this, I have yet to hear someone suggest a vaccine could realistically be available until at least next year (which in NFL terms means the 2021 season). Now, it's reasonable that medicine/treatment will be readily available before that point. Especially if they find currently FDA-approved drugs are effective. But there is no way the health community is going to approve vaccinating the entire U.S. population without extensive testing on side-effects first. With that said... It's totally unrealistic that we can all just hide inside for the next 12-18 months, or that our government can keep pumping out stimulus checks to keep the economy stabilized for that period of time. Over 6 million Americans lost their jobs JUST last month. We are already looking at a potential great depression, and it's ONLY been 3-4 weeks since we started locking things down. So unless you want to say goodbye (possibly permanently) to everything that involves people getting together.... sporting events, concerts, theaters, theme parks, restaurants, bars, etc... then society will need to find ways to adapt with the virus floating around.