James Cook means a lot to this offense. For the first time in Josh Allen's tenure, we actually had a capable back who could make a difference. The Bills know it and with Brady's balanced offense philosophy, he will want a work horse back and Cook delivered that in 2024 even playing only 50% of the snaps.
I think the Bills will get something done...Obviously, they are not going to pay him $20M / year like Barkley received.
The Bills are also big on Davis...who can run the ball effectively and catch the ball (that 44 yard play was awesome) and Johnson...
If the Bills cannot find a path to a reasonable contract, then they will most likely trade him. I also see the Bills spend a 3rd day pick on a speedy back.
If James is keen to win a SB, then he will sign for the $12M contract.