Jump to content

artmalibu

Community Member
  • Posts

    1,457
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by artmalibu

  1. 1 hour ago, JOE IN HAMPTON ROADS said:

    Exactly.  several teams traded up to pick players NOT named Mahomes.  Others passed him up or stood pat maybe hoping he would fall to the second round.

     

    No one saw this coming except KC.  Good on them.  That doesn't mean every other team with a top 20 draft pick was asleep at the wheel.

     

     

    It seems like some here think the Bills were sleeping at the wheel.

     

     

  2. 6 minutes ago, nucci said:

    So we don't pick a good player because the team is not good?

     

    They did not trade back to get a bad player, right.  A to corner in the NFL is a big deal.  Of course QBs are the most important...  The Bills for what ever reason were not sold on him, and were one of 10 teams who passed on him.  Also a lot of teams were in better position to trade up to get him than KC and did not.  Add to that one team who passed on him took a different QB anyway.  

     

    I guess half of the NFL should have fired there GM over this......

    • Like (+1) 1
  3. 1 minute ago, Chemical said:

     

    No THIS Mahomes thing is getting a little old. What a loser mentality. Why bother getting anyone good if the other guys are gonna just make him bad by association. 

     

    He would have come in for tyrod at some point and never gave up the job. If we end up playing Jax in the playoffs maybe he wins that game. 

     

    What a joke. 

     

     

    Ok caption Hindsite... 

     

    The year before last when mahomes was sitting on the bench I didnt see much complaining about trading out of the pick. 

     

    When Josh Allen beats Mahomes in the AFC champion game we will see who the joke is on.   

    • Haha (+1) 1
    • Awesome! (+1) 1
  4. The Mahomes thing is getting a little old imo.  Yea they traded the pick away and selected one of the best corners in the league and a 1st round pick to boot.  

     

    As good as Mahomes looked last year try imagine him being a rookie and playing for the Bills last year. How good would he have looked.  Not to mention he took over an offense that was already pretty good and well coached.  

     

    There are worse none pick QBs like Brady, Breeze, Wilson, Rogers.  Only one was a 1st round in the back half and we all know where the other guys were picked.  

    • Like (+1) 2
  5. The way Foster came on during last year and the additions of Brown and Cole the WR group has been dramatically improved  compared to the start of last year.  And as bad as last years group produced it was not all the the WRs.  The OL was not to great as the QB situation was less than ideal either.  JA did not get a preseason to prepare as the starter and was thrown in.  

     

    With this years WR draft class Im glad they did not use top picks on the position.  Other teams showed that they did not think too much of the WR draft class either  first WR off the board at # 15 and the second at #32.  I feel better with the 2 FA pick-ups that I would with the 2 WRs that came off the board in the 1st round.  

     

    I get that forums are for discussion but threads like this are are a little silly.

  6. 3 hours ago, Fred Slacks said:

     

    I am am not saying Josh is great. But after returning from injury he was finding ways to make plays. With the offensive line overhaul I see no reason he doesn’t continue to do so. I’d argue that WR is not even close to the same level of need on our offensive side as is TE and RB at this point. I personally feel like RB may even be more critical than TE. 

     

     

     

     

     

     

    With Shady, Gore, and Murphy I dont see it as a dire need area.  All 3 are good runners and pass catchers...

  7. 2 hours ago, TaskersGhost said:

     

    BTW, "not sure what else he has to do?  

     

    How about be more than perfectly mediocre in the postseason?  

     

    IDK, call me crazy like you guys have, but to me a franchise QB doesn't play average ball in the postseason and rely on the defense and running games to win.  

     

    But here's a straight YES or NO question for you, and very curious than answer.  

     

    If after the 2026 season we look back and Allen's last 8 seasons were to mimic Newton's 8 to a T, would you consider Allen to have played to expectations?  

     

     

    Rushing doesn't a franchise QB make.  Every single franchise QB has an outstanding short-medium game. 

     

    To even hint that Allen's short-medium game is even anywhere in the ballpark of where Newton's is is the definition of ignorance in the matter.  

     

    To add to that point, you cannot name one QB in the modern era, not one, that has even average much less Allen's horrific-ness in the short-medium game that is a franchise QB based on his rushing.  In fact, you can't even name one QB with great passing that is considered a franchise QB because of his rushing.  Wilson's about the closest and Wilson's passing is so much better than Newtons, on TD/INT alone.  

     

     

    A franchise QB is one who gives a team a chance to win.  By land or air I dont give a crap.

    • Like (+1) 2
  8. 11 minutes ago, TaskersGhost said:

     

    BTW, allow me to ask, which of Newton's passing seasons back up the notion that he's a franchise QB to you?  

     

    Just curious.  

     

    And here's a list;  https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/N/NewtCa00.htm

     

    I'll even summarize the seasons: 

     

    21 TDs, 17 INTs, 4,051 Yards

    19/12, 3,869

    24/13, 3,379

    18/12, 3,127

    35/10, 3,837

    19/14, 3,509

    22/16, 3,302

    24/13, 3,395 

     

    As I see it, withone exception, he's a tremendously average passer, low TD/INT rate, average or worse TD production, high INT%, he's known for being a poor leader and numerous other things.  

     

    I think this at least explains the low standards here however.  

     

    One solid season does not a franchise QB make.  I can name dozens of QBs with one great season that were never even considered for that status.  Easily.  

     

    If all we get from Allen in 7 of every 8 seasons is TD production of 18-24 TDs, well, continue to laugh, but again, I can see why some seem to think that Allen's better than he is at the moment.  

     

    11 minutes ago, TaskersGhost said:

     

     

    When you add his rushing production it changes things a bit....

    • Like (+1) 1
×
×
  • Create New...