Out of those 15 nfl coaches and personnel people, how many have a McCown, Hoyer, Sanchez, Manuel, Fitzpatrick, Insert journeyman's name here quarterback line-up under center? If this is the case, I suppose those rankings are objective, but nonetheless biased and relative to one's current QB situation.
I actually watched Carr play a half dozen times last year. He had 2-3 "good" games with one of these unfortunately coming against the Bills. His 49ers game against a dysfunctional team was very good. He couldn't miss. But he had 3 games out of his final 9 with a passer rating above a 75. Hardly finishing strong. He also had a boatload of 1 TD 170 YD games. I know we're QB starved here, but his play didn't get me excited. If he excels this year, I'll gladly eat crow.