This is fair. He's raw as hell, but looked more than just an arm.
He wants to make plays, it almost looked like he knew he was in a competition and his competitors put in a decent lap. This will have it's downsides as he almost pulled a Matt Simms last night.
All in all, pretty much what I expected.
Side note, if Peterman and AJM play decent again next week, are they going to carry all three into the regular season?