Meh, our defense is top five no matter who you ask and our starters at skill positions are McCoy, Watkins, Harvin, Woods, and Clay. I don't see how you can't give an A unless you refuse to on QB alone...which is unfair to any GM. It does help Whaley that he's handling EJ the way he is though (not sinking the team, bringing in competition etc.)
I mean, D-line and offensive skill is off the chart. Everything else (other than QB) should be solid at worst and good otherwise.