Hearing that Vick is the guy for the rest of the season and hearing good things about mike kafka do you think it would be a bad idea to make the trade? I know everyone wants to take someone for the first overall pick but if we traded marshawn and a 4th or maybe 3rd i dont really know maybe he could be had. All I know is Carini would solidify our line for the next 10 years and kolb definitely could be a franchise qb giving up that 3rd is crucial sure but kolb is still 26, hes got a cannon, and can play in cold weather games. I would also way rather aquire a qb with marshawn and a 3rd then a 1st overall for unproven talent... thoughts?