CarolinaBill

Awesome analysis buddy, big black Qb=Jamarcus. Have you ever watched him play? the kid is more like randall cunningham or Vince Young. More like our attempt at VY and Chris Johnson

he reminds me alot of Randall Cunningham, or possibly Vince Young. At this point I like to see more of him before rushing to judgement.

i dont think he's coming out this year

Parcells is remaining with the Dolphins as a consultant, FYI

Im starting both

I hear brohm is quite the student of the game..always watching tape

In that case check out Nate Enderle from Idaho. Exhibit A is the 2009 Humanitarian bowl.

kellen Moore is generously listed at 6 foot tall, has a weak arm and is left handed. He's a great college QB, but he wont even get drafted.

Kirwan thinks trent can start, not that he's a great option, there's a big difference He even says "just to make one thing clear... Trent Edwards is not the answer. He's just an alternative for teams in need." http://chat.nfl.com/front/archived_chat/1130%E2%80%9D Nice to see some of you still like to twist words around so you can make a point and bash someone...real classy

we're backed into a corner now, we gotta draft one and develop him. That doesnt mean we can't pick up a vet to help with the process, but right now, fitz fills that role. My money is on mallett in the 1st, or Enderle in the 2nd/3rd

Winfield went to Minnesota Its Incognito, not Incardona Bulaga is a backup, not starting If your going to B word about something, at least gets your facts straight

did you see this last game? 2TDs including a 95 yd KO return, not too shabby. BTW, J. Best has 2nd degree turf toe injury, may miss some time.

awesome, simply awesome

Right Now I like Mallett over Luck and especially over Locker.

Classy response.

I'd be very interested to find out what tenn is looking for if VY is on the market. He's the only QB of his class to have a winning record as a starter. If the price is right I think we should do it.

short leash for matt moore with a lame duck coach desperately trying to save his season/job. we'll see if JC has the touch

funny how you condemn the team for not having talent, yet berate their decision to acquire talent.

it doesnt just boil down to the character issue. And im not arguing that i'd rather have edwards as a starter at all. Trent flat out sucks, Vick is an exciting athlete, but he's never been the guy that gets it done consistently, and his stats prove that. Combine that with his character and suspension issues, his own admission of laziness in reference to his gameday prep in ATl, and what you have is a guy that I would rather not have on my team. Now if he was a Bill would a cheer for him? of course, its always team over player.

I would LOVE to see the proof that either of those 2 scenarios was viable, Do you have a Link perhaps? or a first hand knowledge from the war room on draft day? Thats right, you dont. Facts are that we took spiller, and to date we havent been able to use him properly. i understand you like best, and thats fine, but the title almost sounds as if you are glad to see spiller struggle just so you can say you were right. Also, fact is Best has missed more time than spiller due to injury in his career, it should be a slight concern.

Yes, the facts of his mediocrity is my only argument. As i said before, inconsistent, inaccurate, high risk, low character. No thanks at the very least you could reply with trent winning % and form some type of rebuttal argument.

thats awesome except he was off the board when we drafted

I didnt say our QB's are so much better now did I? No I didnt. The underlying point is that while Vick is great for the highlight reel, overall, he's not that great, combine his stats with his age, and his record (1 mistake away from a permanant ban)= PASS IMO. And he's certainly not a long term solution.

oh the great overrated mike vick, with his 55% winning percentage, no back to back winning seasons, no 3000 yd passing seasons and career comp % hovering at 50%......PASS :thumbdown:

we have to address the o line if we take mallett, that much is clear. Id rather go oline first and follow with Enderle in the 2nd or 3rd