NoSaint

Or online iq tests aim to be complimentary so you’ll share results and friends click if a great test taker why are you spending a minute per question on a tightly timed test? You should fly through what you quickly know instead of bogging down in working things out. It’s the easiest advice possible and why I said with minutes of coaching there’s little excuse for a college kid to be in the teens

There’s a pretty wide gap between nailing it and what he got. As a college kid it should be a cake walk to land in the 20s with just minutes of prep work with your agent. That said- if he slides far enough and we didn’t burn picks trading up.... I wouldn’t haaaate taking someone like mayfield around 12 or a minor trade up, and then a guy like Jackson later day two. If talking about dedicating serious picks to get to 2 and that doesn’t work maybe taking two swings that each cost less could be an option just to spitball how you could see things land in that scenario: 12 & a 3rd — mayfield 22– linebacker 2 — wr 2 — if a qb like Jackson is sliding because there were so many free agents and high picks maybe I think about it 3- RB Roll into the season with mayfield and McCarron fighting and let Jackson be very low pressure with peterman on the practice squad at that point. I’m not arguing it’s likely but sometimes QBs go slower than expected when fans love them more than GMs really do. It can be hard to tell.

Also, please do start a new thread to so we know it’s not rehashing an old thought and is actually a brand new one

You read a scouting report AND have a feeling? i was feeling pretty good but now I’m nervous.

Yup — if you are making a mock Darnold is the safe pick, Allen is the upside pick rosen tends to be the guy that everyone likes a lot but no ones absolutely in love with. Plus he hasn’t been linked to the Browns via rumors like the other two.

If I recall correctly a 20 is average andslots up to about 100 on an iq test, and every 5 points on the wonderlic really roughly slots up to 10 iq points for bar napkin purposes. frankly, under 10 is in the “are they literate” category as you are getting into just guessing being about the same on average. I don’t mean that as a joke or insult but you have to have a real talk at that point to see if they guy needs special accommodations to learn the system or is just that level of “I don’t care” on a related note, I think teams would be wise to employ some sort of special education person on their staff to help work with guys and identify opportunities for how to better teach some of them. I don’t think an old school coach is the best candidate to come up with a learning plan for someone that might have a disability.

Ultimately it’s not thaaaat different than the 40 or bench or... 1) different positions will curve differently for benchmarks. Guys like your qb or mlb will have higher expectations than a DT 2) there’s a range of “cool, no question he can do the job.” Your wide out running a 4.45, is like you qb high 20s 3) a wr running a 4.3 is fantastic but doesn’t mean he will succeed just like a 47 on the wonderlic doesnt. It’s a nice piece of a picture but the rest has to still come together 4) a 4.6 doesn’t mean you can’t be a WR but I sure want to take another look at the film, maybe ask how you felt about the time, and generally check out the red flag, just like a 17 wonderlic at qb 5) a 4.9 at wr is probably a dealbreaker unless you catch that they tripped. Likewise a 3 on the wonderlic is probably a dealbreaker unless they took it with the flu, have a learning disability and also didn’t have their reading glasses. Its not worthless, but on its own doesn’t tell enough

Or they’ll meet with them all as much as possible as including our own pick our division will have at least 1 if not 2-3 additional of the top 6 or so QBs potentially joining teams. If he ends up on the Jets, it’s great insight, for instance. And the dolphins and pats might also be looking at second tier guys we get linked to. Thats also not a qb.

You think that’s the price to get to 6? That’s probably 2 and maybe 1 if the Browns think their qb lasts til 4

To be fair, we aren’t some totally talentless black hole if we trade away an extra first and extra second and only have normal picks plus some extras late

Just seems a quality reporter would frame that better

Why post draft?

There is an element of remembering that just because people in the new regime weren’t fans doesn’t mean cordy did anything wrong. Tyler could be right, and Glenn still be a fine guy

Or intern on the keyboard

Its easy to work someone in if you think it’s important. A $20m signing bonus is only $4m in this years cap. You just have to choose wisely. I don’t care about the personality a ton— but worry he’s the type that won’t live up to the deal he’s about to get. I also doubt we are trading picks for and giving monster deals to both Benjamin and him. I think our dynamic guy is coming from the draft.

Feeling better after the big fight?!? ?

So not only do you expect our scouts to find the once every 5-10 year prospect at qb but particularly the one that hundreds of professionals missed so we can get him outside the top pick — instead of taking a shot at a guy high this year because those aren’t slam dunks (even though our scouts might see something you don’t)

I think buffalo rushed into that decision. Impulse control always seems to be an issue.

How do you jump on that one guy unless you know something no one else does?

But that’s why this is a tough poll- where they land is huge. If the reports are true that the saints like mayfield I’d be a lot quicker to vote him than if the jets do. I don’t think any of these guys are the once in a generation talent that is a slam dunk to be good anywhere they go. How often do you see those guys though?

Beyond that — I think maybin was the most foreseeable bust probably. Dude barely qualified as a sack artist in college. Im curious if he meant biggest bust or worst pick. Subtle changes in interpretation can make a big difference in the discussion. Big mike was the big bust... but was he the worst pick?

Generally top picks are a coin flip so it makes sense we’d see a split

Are you lonely at home? It feels like you might be lonely.

Say it 8 times. You may not be personally defending it but you shouldn’t be surprised when you post a possible explanation and you receive a response that doesn’t agree with the take. It’s not like i burst in insulting you but simply said if you have the rights to a guy there’s no reason to move on until it’s accomodating another move. Weve had this discussion a few times with other decisions Beane made (firing the scouts and then rehiring a few for instance).

I tend to agree. Which is why it felt to me like there was some sort of personal animosity between them and felt uncomfortable with the timeline (again could be nothing) Im all for justice but think that includes taking emotions down and following the fact patterns and giving even criminals a fair shake to defend themselves.