It’s completely rational. Before last night, it was already a questionable move to allow KC to move up and select the fastest WR ever. And then the same player goes out and gets a 20+ yard rushing TD and 30+ yard receiving TD.
They were saying on WGR this morning that in past however many years, only five players have accomplished that feat in a game. Four of the five have been on Andy Reid coached teams, including the likes of DeSean Jackson and Tyreke Hill.
It’s totally rational to have been skeptical of the trade when it happened, and at least continuing to be skeptical after last night, if not more so.
It’s irrational to not be skeptical.