-
Posts
5,477 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Gallery
Profiles
Forums
Events
Everything posted by starrymessenger
-
Which new wave band is your favorite?
starrymessenger replied to Pine Barrens Mafia's topic in Off the Wall Archives
Chrissy & er backup definitely came to mind but y'know "The Beat" Rockpalast Hamburg 1978. Nuff said. -
Which new wave band is your favorite?
starrymessenger replied to Pine Barrens Mafia's topic in Off the Wall Archives
Elvis Costello & The Attractions -
Please name Josh Allen the starter
starrymessenger replied to PlayoffsPlease's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Don't really understand all the bad humour surrounding the QB controversy (such as it is). I take a step back and what I see is more ability, more talent and more promise at the position than the Bills have had in a very long time - regardless of who gets the start vs the Ravens (which should be Nate IMO). -
Peterman Cumulative Preseason Stats
starrymessenger replied to The Bills Blog's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Ok fair enuf, so Chad is the one example of a good NFL QB with maybe less than NFL adequate arm strength. Fact remains, two of the greatest ever QBs had only adequate arm strength. Nothing special. As well as other successful QBs. Peterman's arm strength looks to me to be adequate. Nothing more nothing less. -
Peterman Cumulative Preseason Stats
starrymessenger replied to The Bills Blog's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
I agree. It looks to me like his arm is (not great but) NFL adequate - like Joe Montana, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning (2012-2014), Chad Pennington etc... adequate. If he fails lack of arm strength will not be the reason IMO. At the max of his range I think he can throw the ball 40-50 yards downfield if he has to. How many passes in a game travel more than 45 yards. Pre and post snap reads, the timing of throws, accuracy etc... are all more important. I think he will probably go as far as his smarts take him, which might be a long way. -
Peterman Cumulative Preseason Stats
starrymessenger replied to The Bills Blog's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
True enuf 26 but just maybe he can. Now he will get his chance to show just what he can do - and with ample preparation there should be no excuses. Of course we should probably also take into consideration that he won't be behind a solid offensive line throwing 10 yard crossing patterns to the likes of Rice and Taylor who then take it 90 yards to the house. -
peterman will start, always the plan
starrymessenger replied to The Final Word's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
JMO but it seems pretty obvious that NP will start vs the Ravens. He's clearly been the best of the three QBs this preseason and gives the team the best chance of winning. I don't know when the announcement will be made, maybe the Bills want to keep the opposition guessing, but Peterman should be getting the great majority of first team reps from here on in. -
Every Josh Allen snap in Bengals Preseason Game 3
starrymessenger replied to cd1's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Not cutting Vlad any slack because he doesn't deserve it, but Geno Atkins has one of the best bull rush moves in the game. That's why he gets around ten sacks a year as an interior defensive lineman. Such an excellent player. Im not so sure. -
Vontae Davis is a problem....
starrymessenger replied to Bronxbomber21's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Kinda black humour but I chuckled seeing Ross run circles around two Bills defenders falling all over themselves. Was like the greased pig thing they do at state fairs. Wont be funny if it continues tho. -
Every Josh Allen snap in Bengals Preseason Game 3
starrymessenger replied to cd1's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
He's done the same sort of things in season - punting when the score, clock and field position strongly suggest otherwise. It's what he does. -
Every Josh Allen snap in Bengals Preseason Game 3
starrymessenger replied to cd1's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
True. Quite a few head coaches, even some good ones, are terrible at in game management. I've not been impressed with Shawn in that regard for some time. Allen and the offence needed a lift and a little momentum. Shawn let him down. Also punted once on a fourth and short down around the Bungles 40 yard line. Earned him all of 20 net yards of irrelevant field position. It's preseason and he takes the ball out of the kid's hands. Asinine. Regarding Josh, Yes the line was awful but there were also three or four downs where he could have and should have gotten rid of the ball sooner. He said so himself post game. He looked yesterday a whole lot like he did at times (not the good times) at WYO. JMO but he has more work to do before he's ready to start. -
What Peterman needs to do (amongst other things) is make opposing Ds respect his ability to beat them over the top (as ridiculous as that may sound to some). If he can do that his short passing game (and the Bills run game) will be that much more effective. Of course he will never be able to challenge them in parts of the field that a guy with an arm like Allen can but the TD throw to Streater that was called back travelled 40 yards in the air and was perfectly placed. Streater did not even have to push off to beat the corner, the timing and ball placement was so good. I think his useful range is probably around 50 yards. If he can be very accurate with it that should be good enuf, and he is said to have "long ball" accuracy. It cannot be a staple of his game for a obvious reasons but he doesn't need to do it except occasionally, for example when Ds are playing 100% underneath. He wouldn't be throwing ropes either but if he gets rid of it quickly his receivers can run under it. If he can't do it there's a chance, perhaps even a likelihood, that his game eventually gets snuffed out. Conversely if he can do it his game, and the Bills O, should be elevated to a significant extent. Allen should not be starting now IMO. Maybe later towards the end of the year against weaker opposition if the other guys aren't getting the job done. Andy Reid is said to know QBs. He sat McNabb for most of his rookie year and kept Mahomes off the field in 2017. It's not a universal rule by any means but I think it sometimes makes sense to acclimate these talented prospects gradually, depending on just how raw they are and how good the team around them is. Allen is a raw talent. The Bills don't have many proven, reliable playmakers around him and the line is lousy in pass pro. And Daboll doesn't seem to me to be a ground chuck kinda guy.
-
Peterman Cumulative Preseason Stats
starrymessenger replied to The Bills Blog's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Peterman looks to have the smarts for playing the position. He gets the ball out quick and is generally accurate with it. He obviously has trouble with the quick out but I think he can make that throw well enough to his left. All the picks and near picks have been to his right, and that's a more difficult throw for a right handed QB. It would be nice if he could improve on that. Maybe he can, maybe he can't. Hes had a strong preseason and looks to have settled down after his rough rookie year. He is showing great composure for a second year QB with almost no in season experience. Thing is we still need to see how he performs when the games count. There will be a significant step up in game speed and complexity in the defences over anything he's seen so far in preseason. So the jury is still very much out IMO. If he continues to play at this level as the Bills navigate a very difficult schedule, and especially after DCs have had a chance to game plan for him, he will be laying a claim to be considered a potentially starting calibre QB. Josh Allen should not be starting against the teams at the front end of the Bills schedule behind that line. -
I like Rosen too. A lot. We talk about Allen's high ceiling. I think Rosen will get better too. I think the 5 guys taken in the first all could transition as solid starters. I think it was a very good class. IMO when he's on his game Allen is doing more and doing better than any of the other really good prospects.
-
If by analytics we mean stats then you have to disregard them in evaluating Alan. His college stat sheet is bad, except maybe for rushing totals (still much less than Cam's). So it's not just completion percentage. It's the same for every statistical measure. Stats wise he's maybe a fourth round pick. But Allen is legit as an early first rounder. So what gives? What gives is that for all the bad tape (and bad stats) there is as much tape of Allen executing perfectly and when he executes perfectly he is able to get the most out of his physical skill set, which makes him stand out like an adult amongst children. Other athletically gifted prospects with big arms were never as impressive as Allen when he's on his game and doing things the right way. No EJ, Boller, Locker, Losman etc...have tape as impressive as Allen has. And there is enuf of it to reliably conclude that his demonstrated ability is not an accident. After even only a few preseason appearances, we have now all seen Allen make a couple of plays that we know only a handful of the best NFL starters are capable of. Add to that his intelligence, work ethic, coachability and apparent personality/leadership skills and one can easily understand why he would have been completely credible as the 1st pick overall. For sure he is an anomaly but folks can be forgiven for thinking that that he may just be a generational talent. As Jahlen Ramsey has correctly pointed out, Allen's performances against better opposition were worse than against weaker teams. Not making excuses for him but that's sort of what you might expect. And I'm inclined to think that this has something to do with the increased gap between the relative quality of the teams. Allen is clearly a guy who takes it all upon himself and I can see him trying to make up for the differences in skill levels for all offensive position groups. In the pros he will be going against defenders and DCs the likes of which he has never seen, but he will also be playing with much more accomplished teammates (and it looks like he's got a good OC). Even if the Bills may occasionally be overmatched the gap will not be as pronounced as that between his 2017 WYO team and Iowa and he will always benefit from having much more talented options than he had in college. Logically (or analytically) a guy who looked bad against Iowa should look that much worse against a good NFL defence. But I don't think that will happen. I think he will look better, possibly a lot better.
-
NEW NARRATIVE ON TYROD
starrymessenger replied to Wagon Circler's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
JMO but I think Baker will be starting sooner rather than later this year. I remember coach Jackson in Oakland when he had Trent Edwards. After Trent, true to form, threw a four yard out on third and long Hue blew a gasket, went on a rant and publicly excoriated him on the sidelines. Unless Tyrod is able to move that offence down the field given the weapons he has to work with an irresistable tsunami of negative sentiment will sweep Tyrod off the field and onto the bench. -
NEW NARRATIVE ON TYROD
starrymessenger replied to Wagon Circler's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Aka "the drought", so not saying much. -
NEW NARRATIVE ON TYROD
starrymessenger replied to Wagon Circler's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Nobody hates Tyrod. But some folks know him for what he is. And some don't. -
NEW NARRATIVE ON TYROD
starrymessenger replied to Wagon Circler's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Tyrod's a QB impersonator. But at least he is really good at that. Fooled Hue Jackson (though that's apparently easy to do). Also was LMAO at Landry looking shocked at no PI on one uncatchable ball after another. Really can't fathom the network game crews. Can they really be that clueless or is everything scripted beforehand. I guess Romo never got the message. Like that guy. -
Khalil Mack holding out... in Buffalo
starrymessenger replied to YoloinOhio's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
By the time we are ready to compete Edmunds/Mack would make for a devastating combo. I would absolutely do next year's first (and a player - Hughes, whose pushing 30) and give Khalil 20 bucks a year. Or we could just draft Bosa. -
Khalil Mack holding out... in Buffalo
starrymessenger replied to YoloinOhio's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
Lock him up !!! -
Please name Josh Allen the starter
starrymessenger replied to PlayoffsPlease's topic in The Stadium Wall Archives
I don't put much stock in completion percentage. It is to a significant extent actually a team stat more than a measure of QB efficiency. Thing is, JA's stat sheet from his 2017 season is bad disregarding completion percentage. Yards per completion (low) and drop percentage (also low compared with the other first round QBs) are not good. He only threw one pass over forty yards in 2017. Fully 30 % of his throws travelled 5 or fewer yards from the line of scrimmage (and the short game was something he wasn't especially good at). So for a guy with huge arm he didn't exactly use it to stretch the field. There are three different JAs based on his 2017 tape: A guy who looks so good that he seems to be playing in a different dimension than other players, a guy who is mediocre, and a guy who is flat out atrocious. And each of the three Josh's is well represented. Given his extraordinary physical abilities, his intelligence, work ethic, personality I have always been inclined to throw out the entirety of his college stat sheet. Mason Rudolph's stats are much better than Allen's and obviously no one was ever going to draft Rudolph ahead of him. IMO he is worth the big bet that the Bills made in drafting him where they did. And what we've seen in preseason so far is very encouraging. The front end of the Bills schedule is pretty brutal. I wouldn't start him right away. But if he plays very well next Sunday I think McD's hand will be forced. Let's see how he makes out against Atkins (who has also looked great in preseason).