i think he is a polarizing figure because he is such a unique qb. he is a freak athlete, has a great arm, and is a class act and great human being. he is humble, and he is easy to root for. however, he has his limitations, and he plays the most heavily scrutinized position in all of professional sports. he is a flawed gem, and there are many that see him as one extreme or the other. and to me he is somewhere in the middle.