Who cares what the outside world thinks?
I read a post in a gameday thread on Phins something or other that people felt Josh would be a bust based on his first year....I think they were trying to defend Tua.
But a bust? he passed my eyeball test he had/has it all.
And he needed was to be cleaned up and polished like a barn find car
Tua on the other hand has not shown me much in the multiple games I have watched.