All the criticism I have read was in regards to him being a "douche" this year with things like the Superbowl postgame, various in-game antics, whining, etc. I'm not familiar enough with him this season to really speak to whether they were douchey or not. The criticism has all been for things that are recent and on actions he is taking now.
Why aren't they comparing him Johnny Manziel which seem like a more accurate comparison? This seems like trying to cherry pick to fit a narrative.