You don't take into consideration how a young QB can mature and get better over time? Not all quarterbacks are good day one of their careers. The Hoyer of today is NOT better than the Barkley of today. If you're right, then the Bills will cut Barkley and pick up Hoyer today. But you know they will not. I know you will make up excuses like Barkley knows the playbook, blah blah blah. But the simple truth is that Hoyer is old, and Barkley is just better than he is. Look at the Jets game he won last year. Who do you think led the league in completion percentage this preseason? Yep, Barkley. We don't go by the 83 gb rating or the 16 wins in a career because as the old adage says, statistics are for losers!!!