chris heff

That's my point, what has Cassel done in camp to put him in the lead? You could make the same argument about Manuel and Taylor. But to make Cassel the starter just because he is the safe choice is not enough. Cassel is the one that has to significantly out perform the other two not vise versa, because by naming him the starter you are saying that Manuel was a waste of a draft pick and Taylor is not an NFL starter and never will be.

I proposed a hypothetical supposition, that base on no previous knowledge of the players, just camp, who is winning the QB job so far? My reasoning is that Manuel's detractors point to his history of not seeing the whole field and being inaccurate. Taylor has never started. And Cassel hasn't had a good year in five years. If you throw all that out who is wining?

We don't know about recent seasons all we know is what has happened in camp.

If we only knew the QBs as A,B, and C. A, being Manuel, B is Taylor and C is Cassel. We have no knowledge of their past, based on their camp performance, would C be the front runner? Are we missing something that the coaches are seeing? Both A and B seem to have better skill set for Roman's offense. A and B have the possibility of greater upside, but also greater downside. C is better at going through progressions. Is that enough to anoint C? Or is it just the safe thing to do?

Obviously

Oh yeah, thanks

If you tell me about the QBs now, that will be the end of it, i will not look for you I will not pursue you, but if you do not I will look for you and I will find you.

Beat me to it.

Astro, thank you, I was about to send out an APB.

This is exactly what I've been thinking.

Thank you, reports from last night were really confusing. You and John did a better job than so called reporters.

I'm confused, did EJ have a good night or not? Did Taylor have a better or worse night than EJ? Did Rex say Cassel is the leader?

Sorry

So then EJ will not complete one pass tomorrow.

I don't think Astro was going to be there tonight. He ended yesterday's post by saying he'd be back Wednesday.

If Game Pass shows all games why have Directv Sunday Ticket?

I see what you did there.

Based on this list how does Cassel fit in Roman's offense?

Thanks

Obviously Gragg ranthe wrong route and EJ threw where he wasn't supposed to be.

EJ had the Atlanta game won twice. That game should count as two comeback wins. I'm sure some other guys here can come up with one or two more.

Thank you

If Cassel wins I think they are screwed. I don't care if it is Manuel or Taylor. I'm not as down on Manuel as you are. If one of these guys cant beat out Matt Cassel it's back to the drawing board.

But they don't have Alex Smith, they have these guys. I've said this before, if Cassel beats the two young guys, this team is screwed. It would be back to the never ending QB search. Without a QB they are good enough to win enough to not get a very high pick. And good starting caliber QBs rarely hit the FA market or get traded.