chris heff

Got it, thanks

Anybody know how to get broadcast on the internet?

EJ has jaw broken by Mat.

What?

I live in Florida and have for a long time. I have met FSu fans whose opinions are decidedly different. Why are FSUf fans spoiled? Until two years ago they weren't even the best team in Florida, for a decade.

I know, the Gray reception was also qualified.

That's just unbelievable.

I'm guessing his opinion carries the most weight.

Last week Astro posted a list of attributes Roman wants in a QB. That sure didn't describe Cassel either.

And?

I thought Tom Flores was going to be good.

I hate you.

Thanks

So your Polish then?

The first thing you need to understand is that I am the best source of accurate information or opinion. I'm also half Irish, so therefore not prone to hyperbole.

I know Johnny, I just think they will sacrifice some other position and or special teams because they are so unsure at the QB position. Or maybe they are not, it's just us.

I think the keep all three.

Interesting that we have the opposite take on this. You think a tie goes to Cassel because he is a veteran. I think all thing being equal his lack of physical talent makes him the odd man out.

That's my point, what has Cassel done in camp to put him in the lead? You could make the same argument about Manuel and Taylor. But to make Cassel the starter just because he is the safe choice is not enough. Cassel is the one that has to significantly out perform the other two not vise versa, because by naming him the starter you are saying that Manuel was a waste of a draft pick and Taylor is not an NFL starter and never will be.

I proposed a hypothetical supposition, that base on no previous knowledge of the players, just camp, who is winning the QB job so far? My reasoning is that Manuel's detractors point to his history of not seeing the whole field and being inaccurate. Taylor has never started. And Cassel hasn't had a good year in five years. If you throw all that out who is wining?

We don't know about recent seasons all we know is what has happened in camp.

If we only knew the QBs as A,B, and C. A, being Manuel, B is Taylor and C is Cassel. We have no knowledge of their past, based on their camp performance, would C be the front runner? Are we missing something that the coaches are seeing? Both A and B seem to have better skill set for Roman's offense. A and B have the possibility of greater upside, but also greater downside. C is better at going through progressions. Is that enough to anoint C? Or is it just the safe thing to do?

Obviously

Oh yeah, thanks