They say it takes 2-3 years before you can really determine if a draft was any good, so I thought I'd go back and see what people thought in retrospect about prior drafts.
Three years ago ('06):
1 (8) - Donte Whitner, S
1 (26) - John McCargo, DT
3 (70) - Ashton Youboty, CB
4 (105) - Ko Simpson, S
5 (134) - Kyle Williams, DT
5 (143) - Brad Butler, OL
6 (178) - Keith Ellison, LB
7 (216) - Terrance Pennington, OT
7 (248) - Aaron Merz, G
Two years ago ('07)
1 (12) - Marshawn Lynch, RB
2 (34) - Paul Posluszny, LB
3 (92) - Trent Edwards, QB
4 (111) - Dwayne Wright, RB
6 (184) - John Wendling, S
7 (222) - Derek Schouman, TE
7 (239) - C.J. Ah You, DE
Go ahead, grade away.