The initial business model resulted in massive hemorrhage of cash by most teams from the first season. It was a financial disaster. Teams moved around. Fans lost interest.
It was hopeless then as it is now.
The likely issue for the HOF voters is for a guy who "changed the game" for only a handful of plays per week---and as a gunner, not a returner. Tackling a guy returning a punt or a kick doesn't leave a lasting impression. It's not tangible.
Based on what you saw in one game a year ago?
Mckenzie fumbled and "helped lose a game"...is he off your trust list as well?
Singletary has fumbled a whopping 5 times already this season...AND has dropped 4 passes (8.5% drop rate)... and you trust him??
Josh has put the ball on the ground 8 times on only 102 carries--that's a #fumblemachine! Throw in a career high tying 12 ints....you trust him with the ball??
Williams is an NFL zero. There is no logical conclusion you can come to regarding his likelihood of never having a single fumble or never missing a block if he plays more than a single game or gets more than 13 touches.