I was there and thought that it might have been a catch, though it was difficult to see where the toes hit. After I got home, I watched the game and thought it def was a catch.
I have to think that Dick held back on the hankie thinking that the call would be inconclusive and that he'd lose the timeout.
JP looked great yesterday, by the way. Very calm and cool, held on to the ball when hit, and making the throws when he had to.