I'm not saying he's anything close to Farve but...it's way too early for ANYONE to make a final judgement on him...case in point....
“He was a wild and crazy quarterback in Atlanta in the games I watched,” Thompson said. “He did some great things and he did some things that kinda made you scratch your head.”
Still, as late as the mid-1994 season, not everyone in the Packers’ football offices was sold on Favre. After Favre sprained his ankle at Minnesota and gave way to promising Mark Brunell, Holmgren polled the coaching staff the following Monday on whether Favre or Brunell should start the next week against Chicago. The Packers were 3-4 at the time, and Favre’s passer rating was below 75 points in three of the previous five games, including 25.8 points against the Vikings.
At least a couple of assistant coaches said Favre was too undisciplined and advised going with Brunell. Holmgren stayed with Favre, who threw five touchdown passes in a win over the Bears the next week.