Shanahan's Horseshoe

So brave. How about a Kimmel and all the hateful BS he spews and lies about on a nightly basis. Any thoughts there?

He played his best game of his career. He looked like a superstar. My concern moving forward is leaning on him too much. I’d like to see us at him lightly next week

I love Josh but he’s fried. He started looking like this against the Bengals last year. He’s not the same guy right now. Anyone saying different is in denial. It hurts to say that

anything good? i’m about to finish this Sazerac store pick

it’s not the defense. it’s not McD. it’s not the skill. it’s not Dorsey. It’s Josh. kills me to say that but it’s true.

please explain

i’d go a step further and say Dorsey should come down on the field and recover cooks fumble, catch Davis’s tipped ball and caught Kincaid’s third down drop

LOL

Dorsey with another bad throw

LOL how about the three previous drives?

Dorsey getting exposed tonight

Dorsey strikes again!

Man Dorsey is so bad

Dorsey sucks

They do things differently but the result is the same. Expect Cook is an abomination in pass pro. Neither has any business being a #1.

I’ve been very critical of Beane even though I really liked his off-season as a whole. To me, this defense would be humming if we didn’t have the devastating injuries. Also it’s pretty clear that Groot’s foot injury is really impacting his play. That side of the ball is a mash unit. Beane’s biggest problem is drafting way too many developmental guys and playing them early. Spencer Brown, Cook, Williams, AJ all were over drafted and thrust into action before they were ready. Then we wait around for years to develop but the growing pains don’t outweigh the eventual production. I still AJ and Cook are incredibly limited. Brown has turned into a serviceable RT after years of terrible play.

Agree with everything you said outside of the cheating. Yes sign stealing happens. Yes coaches share “scouting reports”. No, teams don’t sneak staff on other teams sidelines dressed up as a coach to “scout”. I could go on and on but nothing Michigan did was normal. The mere fact that Gattis won the Broyles award is the most damming piece of evidence. That being said, I’d take Harbaugh in a second.

He’s a winner but a big time weirdo. The change from McD to Harbaugh might be too much of a culture shock. That being said, there should be a lot of roster turnover so this might be the best time to shake things up. He’s a top 5 coach in all of football. I don’t have faith that McD is a championship coach so I say let’s do it.

Spot on.

Seems to be a bit of a disagreement between Marino and Turner from cover 1 who I think are the best. Turner thinks Dorsey’s scheme is predictable and one note. Marino says it’s pretty much Josh. After watching Turners criticisms I tended to lean more toward Marino. There are guys open. Josh ain’t seeing them and locking in presnap way too much.

Harty had a solid year in ‘21 500+ 16 YPC and then he got hurt. Now that he’s healthy I thought thats how they would use him. Get him upfield to threaten the safeties and let Kincaid and Diggs work their magic underneath with the occasional deep shot but we just haven’t seen a ton of High low concepts with Harty in the game. I don’t understand it.

Yes thank you Brittany 😂

Cook is averaging 3 YPC in our 4 losses. 25% of his yards came in 4th quarter blowouts. He’s always been a complimentary back and this season once again prove it.

Something happened to Josh after the Demar situation. He also broke up with his longtime girlfriend around that time. He‘a shown glimpses of greatness since but has never completely returned back to his old self IMO. Pure speculation on my part.

I’m taking a wait and see approach. If we don’t make it to the Super Bowl in year 5 with an aging roster we need a new process