Historically, teams with good running games and top defenses and average QBs make the playoffs and sometimes even the Superbowl. Also historically, teams with great passing games, average running games and average defenses (may make the playoffs but no SBs (Dan Marino comes to mind). I'd take the team with an average QB, good D & rush game. Take LOT, NT, LB rds 1-3, WR or TE rd 4, QB rd -5. Rd 6 & 7 is special team fodder. Also must sign a ROT, NT, WR and OLB in FA.