You need to focus your argument. Your most recent claim regards QB Rating. Ok, let's go with that. Fitz' career rating is 75. Last year, 79.1. Unspectacular, but improving.
Vince Young? 74.4 career rating. Pitiful 60.8 last year.
But we should go with Young, right? Because he's a sloppy ho instead of a mediocre looking prude...or something?