Alphadawg7

Campbell should either not be on the list or be on there but below McD. I love Campbell, but make not mistake about it - he has cost them playoff losses and key losses in regular season over his stubborn decisions. What he did vs the Cowboys with the #1 seed on the line is one of the single stupidest decisions I have ever seen in a HC. He also had bad end game decisions against the Bills and in the playoffs too that led to losses. I love his attitude, approach, brovado - but there is a time and place for it, and his in ability to control that and find that balance has cost the Lions seeding and playoff exits. That being said, if he can learn from that, he is on his way to being a great HC - like I said I am a fan of his though, just its not quite polished as it needs to have been yet.

I will play - McD - No other HC has more wins against Cheifs than McD. Paytons defenses have been worse than McD's and his playoff record and let downs are worse than McD's. So I will take McD over Sean to beat KC - and quite honestly, I think we will if we see them in the playoffs this year, but the team that concerns me more this season though is the Ravens. They are in tact and had a strong draft. They will be very tough again and our ability to get past them will come down to how defense improves between our FA and Rookie additions.

Where did I say he should have been fired? I said without a SB win that missing the playoffs 3 straight years also following being suspended a season is not something many coaches survive WITHOUT the SB win on the resume. McD's record is better by most measures except the SB win - yet there is no way McD survives getting suspended a season and then missing playoffs 3 straight years with McD. And to say he is miles better because of some list is silly. There is no way Tomlin and Stefanski are better HC's than McD and yet they are on this list for example. These lists are not in anyway proof of anything other than a list one person made and published. So you are giving Sean credit for a 2nd SB win, in which he didn't even reach, because he got a bad call in the playoffs? So why are you not giving McD a theoretical SB win then after the Refs stole the game this year first not giving Kincaid the first down on 2nd down when he was nearly a yard past the FD marker and then again not giving Josh the first on 4th down when he was clearly there? That was at least an 11 point, maybe a 15 point swing in the 4th quarter of a game we were up 1 with. Chiefs got the ball back and scored plus a 2 point conversion to go up 7 when we should have had the first (twice) and were already in FG range and yet would have had a first and still a chance to score a TD as well. So sorry - to say Sean would have had another is 100% hyperbole as they not only didn't win the game they were in, you don't know if they would even win the next game or not. And given they were in a game where 1 call could swing it shows they were not so dominant that you can just give them a "gimme" on any other games after that. I get you are a Sean fan, nothing wrong with that. But I don't agree there is this massive gap between Sean and McD, and again, if McD wins a SB, his resume will be better than Seans by most metrics, and will have done it with less to work with around Allen. You spend every offseason criticizing the weapons around Allen, meanwhile Brees had Colston, Graham, Kamara, Thomas, etc and they still won single digits 7 times, had plenty of bad playoff exits, and missed the playoffs 6 times.

Dont get me wrong, I still think hes a very good coach, just more talking about how a SB win masks a lot of other things that wouldn't be so overlooked without the SB win. And nothing I am presenting is to take away from his SB win either, just more pointing out how different things look once you win one. Most coaches don't survive either the suspension or the 3 years straight missing the playoffs with a QB like Brees - unless they have that SB check mark on their resume. And a lot of coaches also wouldn't survive the poor playoff record outside the SB season either with prime Brees, Kamara, etc either. So, I think he is just being over valued here a little bit due to the one major achievement in one of his 15 seasons as the Saints HC. And as I said before too, if McD wins one say this season, all of his metrics as a HC will be better than Seans - the thing he lacks is the one ring. And don't get me wrong, that is a BIG lack, so McD has to go get that done and if he doesn't this season, then consideration for a change will be warranted.

No. Is it possible? Sure - is it assured, not at all. The only year Sean won a SB or even reached one was when the Saints were riding an emotional high from the Katrina disaster and their defense was actually making plays. Outside that, he struggled to even consistently make the playoffs with Prime Brees, Kamara, Graham, Thomas, Colston, and a load of other offensive firepower and talent through the years. The amount of high end or elite weapons Payton had compared to the Bills is a wide gap, and yet Sean and all his offensive genius missed the playoffs several times or got bounced early. Sean missed the playoffs 6 times with Brees in his 15 seasons there (16 but he was suspended 1 in 2012). In half the seasons in NO that he coached (not counting the 2012 suspended season) he won single digit games of 9 or less. He missed the playoffs 3 straight seasons with prime Brees. Again, the bulk of Seans time there included an all time Great in Brees in his prime and a lot of elite weapons around him yet the results were not always stellar and even in their best seasons were losing in the first or 2nd round, including winning 11 games and losing in the first round to Seattle who got in with a losing record with only 7 wins. So he isn't the fix it all savior I think some see him as. If it wasn't for the one SB win, his overall record would be much less impressive and quite honestly, he probably wouldn't have kept his job after 2012 suspension and would have also probably been fired sometime during the stretch where he missed the playoffs 3 straight years with prime Brees. Imagine McD missing the playoffs 3 straight years with Allen.

I am not here to say who is better or not between Payton and McD - that is subjective. But I will say using "way better" is an exaggeration. While Sean is a great coach in general, lets not also forget he and the Saints struggled to even consistently make the playoffs in NO with prime Brees, he had a lot of things that became critical of him while he was in NO as well. He is a prime example of how a SB ring can mask a lot of things and make people forget a lot of things. Would I put McD ahead of him - no, at least not yet, but I also don't think its fair to say Sean is "way better" either. If McD wins a SB this year, his body of work, win %, and track record will all be better than Sean's.

You do know that Allen made some of those bad decisions in the final drive of the Houston game and its why McD was pissed on the sidelines right?

McD is not only better than several coaches on that list, but if him and those coaches he’s clearly better than were fired tomorrow, McD would be hired first. He should be around 6-8 on that list depending on one’s perspective, and a SB win moved him easily into the top 5.

Kolb’s career ending slipping on a mat before ever playing a snap for Bills. Honorable mention: Duke Williams game winning TD catch and the false hope of future contribution it created lol

Im excited to see the new additions in this defense and I am excited to see what year 2 in the Brady led offense will look like. Really interested in seeing our draft class and also Cole and what they can do this year. And also very interested in seeing Keon and his development. And as someone who wanted to add Moore when he was in the draft and then a Jet, also excited to see if he can be earn the playing time to make an impact.

Yeah it really is sad story - and its why I think its wild when people get so upset when people like Cook or other athletes try to get what they feel they can or what they are worth. What these guys risk and sacrifice to play this game to entertain us is significant, so much so its resulted in tings as extreme as deaths. I know the Seau family, and Jr. Seau's situation was so tragic and devastating for so many. My wife and I are die hard football fans, we have two young boys, and my 2 year old has athlete written all over him. We both day dream of him being the QB for my Bills or her Niners at some point - but the reality is we would much prefer they became stars in Golf or something instead. Never really thought too heavy about the risks of football until I had 2 sons...and while we dont currently have any plans to prevent them from playing, we are both secretly rooting for them to dominate at Golf instead.

And thats great he said that - but its still nothing more than lore that Stevie did much against him which was the point from the get go.

Imagine getting your a** whooped over and over again by the same person in a fight and still chirping and calling them a p*ssy and talking sh*t lmao. Maybe Hill is related to Daniel Cormier lol

So he averaged 37 yards a game lol. As I said, his success against Revis is nothing more than lore.

No offense - this is complete fan lore off one TD in one game. His catch % is like 40% against Revis and the Jets in the games Revis played. The only 100 yard game Stevie had in his career against the Jets was the year Revis played just 2 games that season and didn't play in either Bills game.

Your welcome and all good, totally get it. I was more just saying Burrow played 17 games last year and the summary talks about his missing time. So just makes me wonder what else the AI maybe isn't getting accurate. I have had some AI accuracy issues before myself when having it pull or compare some statistical data.

First, was a cool read and cool work. Ive been using AI to do some really cool things, and seeing others use it in cool ways is always interesting. So kudos sir But this here makes me wonder about the accuracy, as one of the issues with AI is consistent accuracy in some use cases. Burrow played all 17 games last year and didn't miss anytime. He did in 2023, so if it is coming to conclusions where its weighing time missed by a player who didn't miss anytime it brings into question what other factors its miscalculated.

Shakir is an easy choice for me. I know, shocker lol But man he’s exciting when he gets the ball, and he’s just a great guy on and off the field and easy to root for. He also puts the work in to be the he best he can be and that carries a lot of weight with me. I also really like Dion, Keon, and Hairston in terms of just their demeanor and personalities as well. Just fun guys and fun guys to root for.

Wait - is there some sort of silly conversation going on about Tua vs Allen? What is happening. Tua's own mother wouldn't choose Tua over Allen, they are not in the same league. Take away Tuas first read and good luck with that. This is the kind of silly conversation that happens when people try and form conclusions on cherry picked items from stat sheets. This is some pink offseason stuff lol

Well at least he finally found a way to go 1.01

Week 1 is going to be a big week for seeding in an already tough AFC. Whoever wins this first game essentially has a 2 game lead in the seeding race as they will be both up one and possess the tie breakers too. So I like the fact the Ravens are over focused on the past and may press more. Let them bring that emotion into the game as it will start to work against them once something doesn't go their way and the start pressing too much.

Again, sure it would be better if no players went to our rivals. But, we can say the same thing about the Bills additions - If Hairston contributes to just one win or Moore, Sanders, Landon, Palmer...etc. Every team can play that game this time of year after adding FA's and Draft Picks - if said new addition can just help them add one more win. End of the day, Bills are in a loaded AFC, it won't be easy regardless if its Ravens, KC, or someone else. Bills need to just handle their business because if we don't there are several teams ready to step in front in the AFC and more on the rise. So I don't really this making our path to the top seed any different. The floor for the top seed in the AFC this year is 13 wins IMHO, and might need 14 or 15 to secure it. Week 1 will be a big moment in that battle as it immediately puts one of the top contenders 1 game back and on the losing side of a tie breaker so its more like a 2 game lead at that point. Bills handle their business at home, Ravens threat for over taking us in seeding takes a big hit.

In all fairness, he was the 25th ranked CB last year when healthy and he has rarely even been healthy the past 4 seasons. So he first needs to stay healthy and then needs to see if he can find his old form again. Benford was the 5th ranked CB last year for reference. I would have preferred he signed in the NFC too, but this move doesn't particularly worry me either. If he can stay healthy, I suspect he probably plays better there than he has the last 2 years in GB battling injuries which would be good for the Ravens. But that is a big if... He has only played in 14 games since 2022 He has missed 32 games the past 4 seasons since 2020. So staying healthy is a real question mark for him, and how well he can play after all these injuries the past 4 years is still a legit question which is why I am not overly concerned about the move either. FWIW - I know a lot of big GB fans that were not sad to see him go.

First...let me just say, this is all subjective, no wrong answers here Mahomes is more than just clutch though. When he had proper weapons he was setting NFL records. With bad weapons his personal stats have taken a little hit...but it doesn't change the fact they still win, and win a lot and because of him. Mahomes has been a starter for 7 years and gone to the AFCCG or more in all 7 season consecutive seasons and was the #1 seed 4 times. He has 5 SB appearances in those 7 years with 3 Rings to go along with multiple MVPs and SB MVP's. And he was the main reason for all that success, not like he was coasting behind a dominant team where he wasn't leaned on. Fun question: Do the Chiefs reach 3 straight Super Bowls if Lamar is there instead of Mahomes? What about Burrow instead of Mahomes? I don't think they reach any Super Bowls the past 3 years with either guy over Mahomes personally and Josh probably was 1 or 2 under his belt instead. So for me, a QB who hasn't made the playoffs since 2022 and another who hasn't been able to perform at the same levels in the postseason are not leap frogging a guy who just went to his 3rd straight SB despite an inferior cast around him for the past 3 years and has a 100% success rate of reaching the AFCCG every year as a starter for all 7 seasons. NOTE: I do think playoff performance means more than regular season performance too as you can only be a champion winning in the post season when the pressure and level of opposition are all higher.

I get what you are saying about Hurts and "clutch" stuff...But Mahomes isn't just clutch, hes proved elite QB play and statistical dominance, and more single season dominance than even Allen, Lamar, or Burrow has shown in their best seasons, when he had legit weapons in different seasons. But since Hill was traded, Kelce has slowed down some with age, his WR's have been mostly trash or hurt, and he has had a mediocre run game and meh OL the past 3 years. Still - 3 straight SB's and 2 rings. Burrow has missed the playoffs 2 straight years throwing to Chase and Higgins. Lamar had better weapons and Henry who had one of the best RB seasons ever yet didn't last long enough to even face Mahomes in the AFCCG. It's all subjective, so really no wrong answers here - but IMHO I think you are weighing recent stats a bit too much over talent/ability and not giving the difference in personnel enough consideration into why the stats favor the others more recently.