as it would be a huge stretch to put kelly holcomb in the company of any of the group 2 quarterbacks before penningtons rotator cuff injury...........and like you say about eli manning, how bad will he look before showing marked improvement.......with that pedigree, and what he had shown at ole miss, sooner or later he would catch on, the trick is not giving up on him which is what you can say has happened to everyone of the qb's in group 1, less Carr, but the group 2 guys werent moved in and out of the line up
surely a guy from Tulane whom a team traded for to get in the first round of an nfl draft is more promising than an undrafted guy from Middle Tennessee State.......